No, they are not !!!!!!!! Consider how the behaviors of young people have gone down hill after dr, spock. It is written, “spare the rod snd spoil the child.”<><me
I was spanked as a child, and it only took one spanking. After that , my Dad would warn me with “Do you want a spanking?”, and my answer was an instant “No”. It kept me from making additional mistakes.
The parent needs to administer the spanking so the kid realizes why they’re being punished. There is a huge difference between a spanking and a beating. Beatings are abuse, not discipline.
When I was a kid I got spanked occasionally, and I preferred it to other punishments like grounding or having the TV taken away for a week. Spankings are done and over with quickly. I didn’t like them of course and tried to avoid them, sometimes when we got out of line my dad had only to start removing his belt and we got back in line quickly.
It depends on who the child is, maybe. I know some kids that would burst out crying with just a firm look, and others that need a more direct approach. I never minded being sent to my room, my imagination was similar to Kate the Great (check out Sherpa comics), so being sent to my room meant more play time, unless it was to wait for a spanking.
Spanking today is considered abuse. In my day, it was considered proper punishment. Look at kids today compared to kids of 30 + years ago. BIG DIFFERENCE!
Personally, I think it depends on the kid. I got spanked too on rare occasions, but for me the revoking of privileges like TV, time with friends, etc. seemed to be more effective. If you take away what a kid loves, like TV or video games for a week or two, than can work wonders more than a few swats on a behind that can be soon forgotten
JayBluE about 11 years ago
Or her self-centered ones….
elysummers about 11 years ago
Amen to that. Dang people.
awdunn2484 about 11 years ago
No, they are not !!!!!!!! Consider how the behaviors of young people have gone down hill after dr, spock. It is written, “spare the rod snd spoil the child.”<><me
StratmanRon about 11 years ago
If done consistently, they work on some children.
I was spanked as a child, and it only took one spanking. After that , my Dad would warn me with “Do you want a spanking?”, and my answer was an instant “No”. It kept me from making additional mistakes.
dzw3030 about 11 years ago
The parent needs to administer the spanking so the kid realizes why they’re being punished. There is a huge difference between a spanking and a beating. Beatings are abuse, not discipline.
alondra about 11 years ago
When I was a kid I got spanked occasionally, and I preferred it to other punishments like grounding or having the TV taken away for a week. Spankings are done and over with quickly. I didn’t like them of course and tried to avoid them, sometimes when we got out of line my dad had only to start removing his belt and we got back in line quickly.
Stellagal about 11 years ago
It depends on who the child is, maybe. I know some kids that would burst out crying with just a firm look, and others that need a more direct approach. I never minded being sent to my room, my imagination was similar to Kate the Great (check out Sherpa comics), so being sent to my room meant more play time, unless it was to wait for a spanking.
Stephen Gilberg about 11 years ago
Getting sent to my room worked on me, at least insofar as I felt unhappy and knew why.
Catfeet Premium Member about 11 years ago
Ruthie, invite your invisible friends…I don’t think any of them are boring!
swami mommy about 11 years ago
Spanking today is considered abuse. In my day, it was considered proper punishment. Look at kids today compared to kids of 30 + years ago. BIG DIFFERENCE!
hcr1985 about 11 years ago
Personally, I think it depends on the kid. I got spanked too on rare occasions, but for me the revoking of privileges like TV, time with friends, etc. seemed to be more effective. If you take away what a kid loves, like TV or video games for a week or two, than can work wonders more than a few swats on a behind that can be soon forgotten