Tank McNamara by Bill Hinds for July 13, 2020

  1. Airhornmissc
    Liverlips McCracken Premium Member over 4 years ago

    It’s a complicated legacy. Baseball had lost all its credibility, and its fans, after the 1919 “Black” Sox scandal. They needed someone to clean up the mess. Landis said he would, and he did, but the owners had to agree to give him complete and final authority to make any decision he determined to be in “the best interests of baseball.” He, and successor commissioners through Fay Vincent, retained this authority, and occasionally used it (Landis especially). Then the owners got fed up with having an executive they felt was in their employ (a dubious claim, IMHO) tell them they could not do something they wanted to do. They were able to force out Mr. Vincent and install Bud Selig, one of their own, as figurehead. Now there are pro teams in Las Vegas. We have already had the cheating Houston Astros win a WS. Who will be this century’s Black Sox?

     •  Reply
  2. Fb img 1516982044221
    jagedlo  over 4 years ago

    A “cool name” that comes from a Civil War battle…https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Kennesaw_Mountain

     •  Reply
  3. Ellis archer profile
    Ellis97  over 4 years ago

    Black folks have quite a history with the ancient art of baseball.

     •  Reply
  4. A07653a8 c2c4 4ae8 924d 20adc3172cc0
    Jimmyk939  over 4 years ago

    Name the award after Branch Rickey

     •  Reply
  5. Underdog
    CitizenKing  over 4 years ago

    Ditch the Landis name, he deserves the negative reputation. And he never played the game, so why have him on the MVP? Plenty of deserving pioneers could have the honor. Robinson of course comes to mind, but his name is everywhere already. Makes it seem like his great accomplishments were the only ones being made. Maybe the trophy doesn’t need a name.

     •  Reply
  6. Jock
    Godfreydaniel  over 4 years ago

    Check out “8 Myths Out” for some interesting reading about the Black Sox Scandal that might change a few minds…..I confess I didn’t know the Judge’s name was on the trophy. It doesn’t make much sense, whereas things like the Lamar Hunt Trophy and the Vince Lombardi Trophy actually are perfectly logical. (Yeah, yeah, I’m from Kansas City!)

     •  Reply
  7. Picture
    CrgBeauregard  over 4 years ago

    Not going to be a popular opinion but I don’t like the idea of removing people’s names because by current standards they were racists. A great example is Princeton’s removing Woodrow Wilson’s name from a building on grounds that certain aspects of the civil service were segregated during his presidency. But he also also prevented it from extending into other parts of the civil service, ensured standard pay by duties rather than colour, ordered investigations into a surge of race riots and lynchings in the Midwest and North. By the standards of his day he was not a racist.

    To carry this forward, if 100 years from now Rights have been extended to animals and there are people trying to do that now, do we remove Obama and Clinton’s names from everything because they weren’t vegetarians?

     •  Reply
  8. 100 2451
    RonBerg13 Premium Member over 4 years ago

    Hello 1984.

     •  Reply
  9. Missing large
    Timothy Madigan Premium Member over 4 years ago

    what a whitewash of history this is. Sorry but Landis didn’t create or perpetuate a color line. He didn’t write laws to remove it but he didn’t write laws to keep it in place either. He rules the league following the rules of the game and allowed nobody to break them — outside of that, the owners could do as they wish. In fact, that was one of the reasons he was able to hold the hard line on the rules and punish those who broke them.

     •  Reply
Sign in to comment

More From Tank McNamara