The star account is in Matthew, not Luke. And no natural phenomenon fits it at all well. The Magi rested the day before in Jerusalem, then followed “the star” to Bethlehem, and found that it stopped over Joseph’s house (the stable/manger business is in the Luke version). Now, Bethlehem is south of Jerusalem, and any star that starts the evening in the south then proceeds to set in the southwest, it will never appear straight up.
So, call it a miracle if you wish, but don’t try to make it an actual star, it just doesn’t fit.
Magic Grandad almost 11 years ago
Is it possible, at this wonderful time of year, to just believe rather than all the analysis. That’s all children do and they have a great time.
However, spare a thought for the children that can’t for any one of many reasons.
Captain Colorado almost 11 years ago
Jesus is the reason for the season. Merry Christmas.
Comic Minister Premium Member almost 11 years ago
Agreed Heart.
skyriderwest almost 11 years ago
I think the “Star” Heart is referring to is lying in the manger.
cosman almost 11 years ago
Like how the Three Wise Men’s eyes have quietly cut over to Heart..
pinkdryad Premium Member almost 11 years ago
This is beautiful, Mark. Thank you, and Merry Christmas!
chassimmons Premium Member almost 11 years ago
The star account is in Matthew, not Luke. And no natural phenomenon fits it at all well. The Magi rested the day before in Jerusalem, then followed “the star” to Bethlehem, and found that it stopped over Joseph’s house (the stable/manger business is in the Luke version). Now, Bethlehem is south of Jerusalem, and any star that starts the evening in the south then proceeds to set in the southwest, it will never appear straight up.
So, call it a miracle if you wish, but don’t try to make it an actual star, it just doesn’t fit.
VICTOR PROULX almost 11 years ago
in Hebrew, the word “star” also means “angel”
Decepticomic over 3 years ago
“And his name is JOHN CENA!!!!”