A bit late starting—27 December 2011 will be, if I’ve counted correctly, the eighth day of Hanukkah. Owing to a U. of Chicago connection, I must ask: hamantash or latke? Cf. Latke-Hamantash Debate
Ask me about latkes in early March 2012 and I’ll respond “feh.” Ask me today and I’ll say “you got some apple sauce to go with?” It’s all about the timing. [I love the Chicago debates.]
Sisyphos: Daylight on the 27th is the seventh day this year; the eighth day begins at sundown.
Now, about the theme. While I appreciate that we’re seeing something about a Jewish family, Hanukkah is not a major holiday, it’s the commemoration of a historic event to which customs and traditions have been added. If we’ll see Sam turn down something leavened during Passover, if we’ll see him not be at work on Rosh Hashanah or Yom Kippur, then we’ll be seeing something. Right now, all I’m seeing is a fairly typical misunderstanding of a minor festival.
You forget, the most ancient and primitive of all superstitions is the belief that one knows enough to label the beliefs of others as " ancient and primitive superstitions." Alas, that superstition seems to afflict people regardless of their religious beliefs…
You’ve posted in the past that you are a Detective … right? So detect! It should be obvious to you that Mike and Joe are trying to flesh our Sam’s character by depicting his family and beliefs. After seeing and reading todays strip we have learned a lot about ALL the cast.
@psamI would disagree. Many strips give us the Christian point of view of the holiday season. Why in this strip it is even established that Tracy celebrates a traditional Christmas.I myself am a pagan and I have not problem with (and in fact enjoy) seeing other religious viewpoints in stories.Besides, this means that Sam can celebrate with Colossal Boy, ShadowCat and the Thing for the holidays.
@Mike Curtis Thanks for your response. I do appreciate that – I’m just annoyed at the rest of the world today. :-( Please continue to flesh out the lives of the characters in any way that enhances the strip. All of us who endured the previous version are ecstatic to have you in charge.
The use of actual people (particularly those from this board) is cleverly done. It is a special treat for those “in the know” but yet doesn’t detract from the story for those who are not. Thanks to Mike for bringing us a little extra bit of fun with these guest appearances.
On this day 24 years ago Tracy, Sam, Lizz, and Lee Ebony had just discovered that Dr. Will Carver was the plastic surgeon who screwed up Putty Puss’ face with an experimental technique. Dr. Carver had been in the strip before as the plastic surgeon who gave Mumbles a new face and the same with Haf N Haf. Dr. Carver was eventually killed by Angeltop which angered Putty Puss who wanted to kill Carver himself.
I dig this strip a lot, have since I was a kid. While I understand the “fleshing out” of certain characters is something needed I’d almost rather not see it done if it means stuff like today’s posts about religion. Let’s just catch the bad guys.
margueritem almost 13 years ago
HEY KIDZ!!!
http://tinyurl.com/brpsfeg
margueritem almost 13 years ago
Rabbi Marmelstein looks like he’s based on a real person.
Sisyphos almost 13 years ago
A bit late starting—27 December 2011 will be, if I’ve counted correctly, the eighth day of Hanukkah. Owing to a U. of Chicago connection, I must ask: hamantash or latke? Cf. Latke-Hamantash Debate
Major Matt Mason Premium Member almost 13 years ago
@margureritem: Any relation between Rabbi Marmelstein and Yr. Humble Servant is purely intentional. ;-)
Major Matt Mason Premium Member almost 13 years ago
@sisyphos: Latkes? Hamentashen? I like ’em both! :9
APersonOfInterest almost 13 years ago
I think this must be a first for this strip. Am I correct Team Tracy?
Mdstudio almost 13 years ago
Latkes for me please. This is definitely a first for this strip. How cool!
Warren Snaider Premium Member almost 13 years ago
Ask me about latkes in early March 2012 and I’ll respond “feh.” Ask me today and I’ll say “you got some apple sauce to go with?” It’s all about the timing. [I love the Chicago debates.]
Sisyphos: Daylight on the 27th is the seventh day this year; the eighth day begins at sundown.
Now, about the theme. While I appreciate that we’re seeing something about a Jewish family, Hanukkah is not a major holiday, it’s the commemoration of a historic event to which customs and traditions have been added. If we’ll see Sam turn down something leavened during Passover, if we’ll see him not be at work on Rosh Hashanah or Yom Kippur, then we’ll be seeing something. Right now, all I’m seeing is a fairly typical misunderstanding of a minor festival.
Sorry about raining on the parade.
Vista Bill Raley and Comet™ almost 13 years ago
Good morning all…
Warren Snaider Premium Member almost 13 years ago
I am a champion kvetch – are we lantsmen?
puddleglum1066 almost 13 years ago
You forget, the most ancient and primitive of all superstitions is the belief that one knows enough to label the beliefs of others as " ancient and primitive superstitions." Alas, that superstition seems to afflict people regardless of their religious beliefs…
William Bednar Premium Member almost 13 years ago
Why isn’t Tracy wearing a yellow Yarmulke?
In fact, Tracy does not appear to be wearing a Yarmulke at all!timebear Premium Member almost 13 years ago
@ scuttlebutt99There is no reason to be mean.
APersonOfInterest almost 13 years ago
You’ve posted in the past that you are a Detective … right? So detect! It should be obvious to you that Mike and Joe are trying to flesh our Sam’s character by depicting his family and beliefs. After seeing and reading todays strip we have learned a lot about ALL the cast.
timebear Premium Member almost 13 years ago
@psamI would disagree. Many strips give us the Christian point of view of the holiday season. Why in this strip it is even established that Tracy celebrates a traditional Christmas.I myself am a pagan and I have not problem with (and in fact enjoy) seeing other religious viewpoints in stories.Besides, this means that Sam can celebrate with Colossal Boy, ShadowCat and the Thing for the holidays.
HannoX almost 13 years ago
Hi, Mitch! You’re looking good in today’s strip.
APersonOfInterest almost 13 years ago
Okay, we now know that you don’t agree with what is depicted … but, don’t you believe in freedom of religion? -Chill, brother.
Warren Snaider Premium Member almost 13 years ago
@Mike Curtis Thanks for your response. I do appreciate that – I’m just annoyed at the rest of the world today. :-( Please continue to flesh out the lives of the characters in any way that enhances the strip. All of us who endured the previous version are ecstatic to have you in charge.
johnrussco almost 13 years ago
Sam & Dick take a break from fighting crime for some quality time with family & friends. Now that is cool.
Ray Toler almost 13 years ago
The use of actual people (particularly those from this board) is cleverly done. It is a special treat for those “in the know” but yet doesn’t detract from the story for those who are not. Thanks to Mike for bringing us a little extra bit of fun with these guest appearances.
Ray Toler almost 13 years ago
On this day 24 years ago Tracy, Sam, Lizz, and Lee Ebony had just discovered that Dr. Will Carver was the plastic surgeon who screwed up Putty Puss’ face with an experimental technique. Dr. Carver had been in the strip before as the plastic surgeon who gave Mumbles a new face and the same with Haf N Haf. Dr. Carver was eventually killed by Angeltop which angered Putty Puss who wanted to kill Carver himself.
Buzza Wuzza almost 13 years ago
I dig this strip a lot, have since I was a kid. While I understand the “fleshing out” of certain characters is something needed I’d almost rather not see it done if it means stuff like today’s posts about religion. Let’s just catch the bad guys.