The “proper” way to write a mystery is to figure out the solution first (who did it, how, why, etc.), and then figure out the clues and how they’re hidden, and bring them to the detective’s attention over the course of the story.
That said, I do know that a few legitimate authors (though I don’t know of them by name) who take Jeff’s approach.
Actually Jeff’s way is completely acceptable. There are two types or writers. The Plotter (Who outlines the plot) and the Pantster (who writes by the seat of his or her pants). I often don’t find out until the end or maybe the middle, but I still want to finish the story to see what happens and how it happens. Maybe I’ll come up with a different ending. The characters usually decide on some plot points.
Susan00100 about 4 years ago
Mutt did it—to Jeff!!!
tony_n_jen2003 about 4 years ago
I’ll wait for the movie.
cubswin2016 about 4 years ago
I do not think Agatha Christie would have anything to worry about.
bobgreenwade about 4 years ago
The “proper” way to write a mystery is to figure out the solution first (who did it, how, why, etc.), and then figure out the clues and how they’re hidden, and bring them to the detective’s attention over the course of the story.
That said, I do know that a few legitimate authors (though I don’t know of them by name) who take Jeff’s approach.
donwestonmysteries about 4 years ago
Actually Jeff’s way is completely acceptable. There are two types or writers. The Plotter (Who outlines the plot) and the Pantster (who writes by the seat of his or her pants). I often don’t find out until the end or maybe the middle, but I still want to finish the story to see what happens and how it happens. Maybe I’ll come up with a different ending. The characters usually decide on some plot points.
brklnbern about 4 years ago
Nutcase logic.