Frazz by Jef Mallett for October 16, 2016
Transcript:
Caulfield: Leonard Cohen's "Hallelujah" may be the most covered song in modern music. And his own version is arguably the weakest one out there. All the versions we like are basically...somebody's version of Jeff Buckley's version of John Cale's version of Leonard Cohen's version of his own song. Mr. Spaetzle: If Rufus copied off your quiz, Rufus is in a little trouble. Caulfield: But what if he improved on it, is what I'm asking. Mr. Spaetzle: In academia it doesn't work like that. Caulfield: Also, royalties.
Night-Gaunt49[Bozo is Boffo] about 8 years ago
Neither of those concepts work in college or university. Unless it is science it could work in both ways.
QuiteDragon about 8 years ago
“*Our apologies, but to fight off abuse from the spammers, we now limit our comments to include text with bold and italics only.”Because bold and italics are like Kryptonite to spammers! Dude, how does that work??? Think of all the cash to be made!! Think of all the Viagra messages I won’t have to deal with!!! Tell, tell, tell!!!! /snark
SusanSunshine Premium Member about 8 years ago
QuiteDragon…
I know. That sentence is so badly written,
there have actually been some commenters who thought they’d have to leave, because they didn’t know how to do bold or italics.
I’ve also seen quite a few comments all in bold….and I finally realised those were from people who also think it means
you have to use bold or italics now to post.
Honestly, folks…no.
You don’t.
You can. You don’t have to.
Bilan about 8 years ago
Is Caulfield implying that somebody else can do better than him?
docforbin about 8 years ago
Then again, most people like Jimi Hendrix’s version of “All Along the Watchtower” better than Bob Dylan’s original version (and Dylan wrote the song to begin with).
will about 8 years ago
In Academia it’s called “research”
sandpiper about 8 years ago
Looks like what Caulfield actually is asking is, did Rufus get a better grade or write a more inventive quiz. If so, Caulfield wants some of the credit.
matzam Premium Member about 8 years ago
basically all ideas, inventions, or creations are copied, borrowed from, pilfered, or inspired by a previous person
CanuckAmuck about 8 years ago
This comic is a reference to Rufus Wainwright’s cover of Hallelujah which is unquestionably the very best one.
Nuliajuk about 8 years ago
I’ve heard Bob Dylan’s voice compared to “a small mammal trapped in a heating duct”. The best songwriters usually do the worst versions of their own songs and have the worst voices.
Troy about 8 years ago
Definitely gotta go with Wainwright on this one. Thank you Shrek. “Love is not a victory march…”
57-Don about 8 years ago
I realize that it’s not the point of the strip but Leonard Cohen’s version is my absolute favorite, it’s got more heart than all the others combined
Seed_drill about 8 years ago
Never heard John Cale’s version, but the better singers versions lacked the gravitas of the original.
BTW, how many caught that the other famous cover was by RUFUS Wainwright?
Rob Larson about 8 years ago
The best cover of Hallelujah is by K.D. Lang by far. Her performance at the 2010 Winter Olympics closing ceremony was pure magic.
ravenoverthegreen about 8 years ago
Why is the voice bubble coming from the laptop?
Scoonz about 8 years ago
C’mon guys! Today’s strip was one of the best! Brilliant! And it was such a nice try by the kid.
Please don’t be dissuaded by that one nagging, negative guy who hates this strip with a passion that knows no bounds. Tune him out and enjoy it for it’s briliance. Please!
ellisaana Premium Member about 8 years ago
Dylan isn’t Nobel Laureate for his voice, which, like most singers, has changed over his lifetime. Dylan’s true genius is in his lyrics and the fact that he has influenced so many singers in so many genres – folk, rock, country, blues, gospel, even proto-rap.(for a rap example listen to- Subterranean Homesick Blues © 1965 Bob Dylan)
Uncle Bob about 8 years ago
I never heard a version I didn’t like…
hippogriff about 8 years ago
Nuliajuk
At least that was better than Oscar Levant’s description of Louis Armstrong, “A frog with a man in his throat.”
Happy, happy, happy!!! Premium Member about 8 years ago
The most covered song in history is The Beatles song Yesterday.
Busker Jim about 8 years ago
“Hallelujah”? Leonard Cohen? More Canadian references? I love it! :D
childe_of_pan over 7 years ago
Leo Kotke described his own voice as sounding like “geese farts on a muggy day”.
childe_of_pan over 7 years ago
There are a lot of singers who owe a great debt to Dylan; prior to him, it was assumed that a recording artist would have a good singing voice. Dylan broke ground for all those folks who had great songs but ‘unusual’ voices.