Coming Soon š At the beginning of April, youāll be
introduced to a brand-new GoComics! See more information here. Subscribers, check your
email for more details.
Caulfield: Music comes from the heart, right? Frazz: Right! Caulfield: Then where do waltzes come from? Frazz: True. Hearts don't beat in 3/4 time. Caulfield: And how on earth did Dave Brubeck survive playing "take five"?
Where the jukebox is blastinā and the liquor is flowinā An occasional bottle of wine Thatās ācause everyone here is just more than contented To be livinā and dyinā in three-quarter time
For all you non-musicians out there, there is no such thing as three quarter time. It is called three-four time, referring to the number of beats in a single measure and the note value (in this case, a quarter note, or one quarter of a whole note). This is called the time signature.
There were early attempts to ban the waltz for that reason..I thought Johnny Desmond did Take Five.āThe only 9/8 I knew were Beautiful Dreamer and Blessed Assurance. If you want something really jarring, try the former tune with the latter lyrics. Make sure you have had your insulin..Strod: In grams per meter per joule, the most efficient is a man on a 15 speed bicycle. If you donāt think that is practical, how quickly they forget the Ho Chi Minh Trail..Rapid change in tempo is quite common these days. High school bands do it in competition quite regularly.
I first thought 2/4 time, but the beats arenāt regular, so maybe it is 3/4 ā with a rest at the end of the bar. But that rest is longer than the interval between the beats. 5/4 might actually be closer. So maybe DAVE BRUBECK WAS ON TO SOMETHING AFTER ALL ā but it was Paul Desmond who actually wrote āTake Fiveā
How about āBlue Rondo a la Turk,ā as long as youāre on Brubeck? But probably 98% of Hank Levyās compositions were in odd time signatures (and I loved playing them). Itās somewhat axiomatic that when he put a 4/4 chart in front of his Towson State University jazz ensembles, they could hardly play the things!
Was listening to an older Brubeck album recently. On it Paul Desmond played āEleven Four,ā which was both the name of the piece and its time signature. It was over four minutes long, and at the end everyone was out of breath ā including the listeners. Made āTake Fiveā sound like childās play.
QuiteDragon: It was first recorded by the Dave Brubeck Quartet. but Desmond wrote it and is featured on the alto sax (his usual instrument in the Quartet). Thus my statement about Desmond did it. It is still a great piece.
Sorry to be nitpicky, but it was Paul Desmond, not Johnny. He was one of the few saxophonists (along with Coltrane and Charlie Parker) I could recognize even with knowing the song.
dps1943 over 9 years ago
āMoneyā by Pink Floyd is partly in 7/8 time.
peter over 9 years ago
Well, that explains why they split up then. ;-)
peter over 9 years ago
Not to mention āApocalypse in 9/8āā¦
Stellagal over 9 years ago
Did anyone check John Cageās heart during 4ā33"?
Bilan over 9 years ago
A manās heart beats at 3/4 time when he sees the low-cut gowns the women wear to waltzes.
Pedmar Premium Member over 9 years ago
Tchaikovsky wrote a 5/4 waltz in one of his symphonies.
whiteheron over 9 years ago
Sorry, but I gotta go with Jimmy Buffet āLiving and Dying in Three Quarter Timeā ā¦ā¦again.
StratmanRon over 9 years ago
Along the same lines, some of Rushās music was odd time signatures. YYZ: 5/4, Earthshine: 11/8, Subdivisions: 7/8
moonlgt Premium Member over 9 years ago
And Brubeckās āUnsquare Danceā was in 7/4!
Strod over 9 years ago
Sure, and the comment is: Bikers ride vehicles that are not very fuel efficient.* Thatās all.Ā Ā
Of course thatās relative to what they can carry. Motorcycles, even big ones, obviously get more MPG than average cars.matzam Premium Member over 9 years ago
luckily I know nothing about time in music. I can just enjoy listening to it
russellc64 over 9 years ago
Where the jukebox is blastinā and the liquor is flowinā An occasional bottle of wine Thatās ācause everyone here is just more than contented To be livinā and dyinā in three-quarter time
coloharpare Premium Member over 9 years ago
They do in Sweden! Most Swedish traditional music is in 3/4āLUB dub, dub, LUB dub,dubā¦.
JanLC over 9 years ago
For all you non-musicians out there, there is no such thing as three quarter time. It is called three-four time, referring to the number of beats in a single measure and the note value (in this case, a quarter note, or one quarter of a whole note). This is called the time signature.
hippogriff over 9 years ago
There were early attempts to ban the waltz for that reason..I thought Johnny Desmond did Take Five.āThe only 9/8 I knew were Beautiful Dreamer and Blessed Assurance. If you want something really jarring, try the former tune with the latter lyrics. Make sure you have had your insulin..Strod: In grams per meter per joule, the most efficient is a man on a 15 speed bicycle. If you donāt think that is practical, how quickly they forget the Ho Chi Minh Trail..Rapid change in tempo is quite common these days. High school bands do it in competition quite regularly.
Rush Strong Premium Member over 9 years ago
Hereās Dave Brubeck surviving Take Five in five-four time.
South2North over 9 years ago
I first thought 2/4 time, but the beats arenāt regular, so maybe it is 3/4 ā with a rest at the end of the bar. But that rest is longer than the interval between the beats. 5/4 might actually be closer. So maybe DAVE BRUBECK WAS ON TO SOMETHING AFTER ALL ā but it was Paul Desmond who actually wrote āTake Fiveā
GoBlue over 9 years ago
How about āThe Oceanā by Led Zeppelin.. Mixed meter. Does that mean someone needs a pacemaker?
Seed_drill over 9 years ago
Brubeck must have been in afib.
K M over 9 years ago
How about āBlue Rondo a la Turk,ā as long as youāre on Brubeck? But probably 98% of Hank Levyās compositions were in odd time signatures (and I loved playing them). Itās somewhat axiomatic that when he put a 4/4 chart in front of his Towson State University jazz ensembles, they could hardly play the things!
Kind&Kinder over 9 years ago
Donāt know if someoneās mentioned it, but Brubeckās āUnsquare Danceā beats āem all for crazy rhythms. One of my favorites.
badeckman over 9 years ago
louieglutz over 9 years ago
time further out, its full of themā¦
louieglutz over 9 years ago
time further out, its full of themā¦
louieglutz over 9 years ago
time further out, its full of themā¦
tomielm over 9 years ago
Was listening to an older Brubeck album recently. On it Paul Desmond played āEleven Four,ā which was both the name of the piece and its time signature. It was over four minutes long, and at the end everyone was out of breath ā including the listeners. Made āTake Fiveā sound like childās play.
chromosome Premium Member over 9 years ago
Gustav Holst wrote the most famous of his Planet pieces, Mars, in 5/4 time.
colcam over 9 years ago
The heart beats in perfect time, but the soul soars beyond time.
hippogriff over 9 years ago
QuiteDragon: It was first recorded by the Dave Brubeck Quartet. but Desmond wrote it and is featured on the alto sax (his usual instrument in the Quartet). Thus my statement about Desmond did it. It is still a great piece.
childe_of_pan over 7 years ago
Sorry to be nitpicky, but it was Paul Desmond, not Johnny. He was one of the few saxophonists (along with Coltrane and Charlie Parker) I could recognize even with knowing the song.