Although difficult to pick a best Doctor, I can easily say that Collin Baker was the worst.
It is a shame that many of the old episodes (William Hartnell/Patrick Troughton) were lost to the world.
The acting and stories are very good in many Doctor Who episodes. This is good since the special effects are often lacking, especially in the older doctors.
ALl Creature Great And Small is my favorite all time TV show. So naturally I’m biased toward Davison being in that role. Though he was memorable as the Dish Of The Day in The Hitchhiker’s Guide To The Universe.
Before we ever got his episodes in syndication, the novelizations of Patrick Troughton’s stories made him MY favorite Doctor! Check out the restored 8-parter The Invasion (of the Cybermen)—they did animation on 3 episodes with the old sound track. It’s great, although Tomb Of The Cybermen is an even greater classic!
If they Colin Baker was the best Doctor Who then I could see the crazyness in the comment. He made Sylvester Mccoy look brilliant. They both also had the worst companions Mel and Ace
I think Hartnell definitely takes the prize if you take his health into consideration. The way he worked his very real memory lapses into his character was really quite remarkable.
Each actor brings his own ‘unique’ interpretation to the Doctor. They ALL are, basically, the same person. But Yeah, Tom Baker was the first Doctor I saw, so I guess that makes him My Doctor, Tennant ties with him.
That must have been some whammy for Roy and Kathy to discuss who played the best “Doctor Who”. As any true nerd would know, the character on the BBC series is referred to as the Doctor. (Peter Cushing played “Dr. Who” in a couple obscure movies.)
I have gone through most of my life thinking Tom Baker was the best /only Doctor…I just realized…I just really liked Leela. I am fond of Matt Smith though.
chireef almost 13 years ago
turn around is fair play
Tue Elung-Jensen almost 13 years ago
Trust me – this means war…
hawgowar almost 13 years ago
Tom Baker is the one, the only, true Dr Who.
Tog almost 13 years ago
I likes Christopher Ecclestone.
Stray almost 13 years ago
They were both better than Tom Baker. Jon Pertwee is my fav…
pschearer Premium Member almost 13 years ago
If best means the one I enjoyed most, definitely Tom Baker.
Dwilesjr almost 13 years ago
I never saw any of Dr. Who so I can’t contribute as I normally do :(
MITHRAND1R almost 13 years ago
Although difficult to pick a best Doctor, I can easily say that Collin Baker was the worst.
It is a shame that many of the old episodes (William Hartnell/Patrick Troughton) were lost to the world.
The acting and stories are very good in many Doctor Who episodes. This is good since the special effects are often lacking, especially in the older doctors.
pschearer Premium Member almost 13 years ago
Colin Baker the worst? Hands down, tho I was never impressed with Davidson. (Pretty good on “All Creatures…” tho.)
Nachikethass almost 13 years ago
Wow! John Zakour, you are an evil man! Roy and Kathy will kill themselves for uttering such sacrilege!
scottartist creator almost 13 years ago
ALl Creature Great And Small is my favorite all time TV show. So naturally I’m biased toward Davison being in that role. Though he was memorable as the Dish Of The Day in The Hitchhiker’s Guide To The Universe.
Happy, happy, happy!!! Premium Member almost 13 years ago
if you put an episode of the doctor in front of me i will watch it. any episode, any Doctor…its all fun.: )
DetectiveKemper almost 13 years ago
Hey, I like Sylvester McCoy.
wynot almost 13 years ago
What did the girls do to them?
johnzakour Premium Member almost 13 years ago
Making a couple fight over the best Dr Who is fitting punishment.
Rhonda Griep almost 13 years ago
It was Tom Baker!!! who was the best Dr Who!!!
jmo328 almost 13 years ago
Seeing as Tom Baker was the 1st Doctor I ever watched, he will always be my favorite.
furnoir almost 13 years ago
Before we ever got his episodes in syndication, the novelizations of Patrick Troughton’s stories made him MY favorite Doctor! Check out the restored 8-parter The Invasion (of the Cybermen)—they did animation on 3 episodes with the old sound track. It’s great, although Tomb Of The Cybermen is an even greater classic!
Cannoneer almost 13 years ago
Exterminate, exterminate, exterminate!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Happy, happy, happy!!! Premium Member almost 13 years ago
i knew that the s**t was going to hit the fan when Roy did his bit to Dana. i should have seen that it was going to overflow here…: D
tylerholt almost 13 years ago
Let the Daliks decide who the best is!
johnzakour Premium Member almost 13 years ago
Only in Working Daze could a star trek argument involve the Jedi Mind trick and end up with Dr. Who argument.
Totalloser Premium Member almost 13 years ago
If they Colin Baker was the best Doctor Who then I could see the crazyness in the comment. He made Sylvester Mccoy look brilliant. They both also had the worst companions Mel and Ace
evangelyne almost 13 years ago
All Doctors. Any Doctor, I don’t care. It’s the WRITERS who occasionally need to be shot!
tsandl almost 13 years ago
I think Hartnell definitely takes the prize if you take his health into consideration. The way he worked his very real memory lapses into his character was really quite remarkable.
Stray almost 13 years ago
Colin Baker was better than Tom Baker (that sound you hear is all the Who fans fainting…)
The audios prove that Doctors 5 through 8 could have been a lot better on television…
MadYank almost 13 years ago
As I said yesterday (well, okay – before reading THIS strip):“Who’s On First?”I rest my case.
rshive almost 13 years ago
As a traveling assistant i thought that Leela was the best. One solution fits all — “Kill them!”
TheDOCTOR almost 13 years ago
Each actor brings his own ‘unique’ interpretation to the Doctor. They ALL are, basically, the same person. But Yeah, Tom Baker was the first Doctor I saw, so I guess that makes him My Doctor, Tennant ties with him.
CaptBullock almost 13 years ago
That must have been some whammy for Roy and Kathy to discuss who played the best “Doctor Who”. As any true nerd would know, the character on the BBC series is referred to as the Doctor. (Peter Cushing played “Dr. Who” in a couple obscure movies.)
johnzakour Premium Member almost 13 years ago
One thing about Dr. Who’s I love watching them once but they don’t have a lot of repeat value for me.
RandomK9 almost 13 years ago
I have gone through most of my life thinking Tom Baker was the best /only Doctor…I just realized…I just really liked Leela. I am fond of Matt Smith though.
bones72 almost 13 years ago
David Tennat the best doctor.