Drabble by Kevin Fagan for December 02, 2014

Bill Murray, hands down

What? No love for Jim Carey?

None! The Muppet Christmas Carol was my favorite. :-)

Oh Magoo! You’ve done it again!

Ralph was right the first time.

The Muppets with Michael Caine as Scrooge rule.

Of the serious performances, I agree with Ralph – George C. Scott had the best performance I’ve ever seen. But in terms of the movie I like to watch most, it’s the Muppet version.

Scrooge McDuck. He was born for the role.

I have fond family memories of the Mr. Magoo version.

Hmmm, Vanessa Williams?

Albert Finney.

Patrick Stewart.

Magoo ROCKS!

Oh please… Michael Caine has them all beat.

I love the George C Scott version but I also loved Patrick Stewart’s version too.

It’s too hard to decide so I just collect every version I can find!!

Reginald Owen (1938)

Two in a row for June.

Alastair Sim. I got the year wrong but it is Alastair Sim….

The Patrick Stewart version goes on my great list, as does the George C. Scott and the Alistair Sim. Ranked only alphabetically, as I said yesterday. Much more fun discussing the various films and what made them all great than it is to have a meaningless series of contradictions.

Albert Finney

alistair sim, alastair sim, alastair sim!!!! I cry everytime and it’s the only thing that makes it truly Christmas for me

she’s right….Alastair Sim hands down!

Jack Palance in Ebenezer/1998

Michael Caine beats them all

I’m still waiting for someone to do all of Dickens’ story.

Absolutely Albert Finney.

I still remember Bill Murray’s as my favorite version.

First one I ever saw was Mr. Magoo ! Love me some Razzelberry Dressing! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Eq1oJJ9M784

Arguing about opinions is so pointless.