Okay, I’m going to use that. I will get my dairy for the day in whipped cream and protein with pecans. If you’ve never had pumpkin pie with pecans and whipped cream, you should.
Here we can cite Nix vs. Hedden, the 1893 case in which the Supreme Court ruled that the tomato is botanically a fruit, and legally a vegetable for the purposes of taxation. The reasoning is that it’s usually used (in cooking) in the same way as other vegetables – it’s eaten as part of a meal, and not as a sweet dessert after the meal as fruits usually are.
The same reasoning applies to squash in general, cucumbers, chayote, green beans, avocados, and olives… botanically fruits, but eaten as vegetables.
Pumpkin pie is an odd case. The pumpkin is botanically a fruit, and not particularly sweet. Cook it up as soup or in a “Three Sisters” Native American stew, and it’s a vegetable. Take that same pumpkin, chop it up, mix with eggs and pour it into a crust and bake it, and it’s pumpkin quiche… still eaten as part of the meal, and it’s still a vegetable.
Puree it as you would for a soup, add sugar and milk and nutmeg and maybe an egg, pour and bake it in the very same crust as the quiche, and it’s pumpkin pie… a dessert, and suddenly pumpkin is back to being a fruit.
… unless pumpkin pie and salad is all you eat at that meal, in which case you’re eating sweet quiche instead of pie-for-dessert, so it’s a vegetable again.
… or unless you put tomato catsup on it, which (according to the Reagan administration) counts as a vegetable.
… or if you put pumpkin pie on your cottage cheese, substituting it for the tomato catsup that President Nixon used to use, and thus making it vegetable-by-analogy.
I hope that all is very clear now. I’ll go have some watermelon now… clearly a vegetable since it’s just a cucumber with pretensions of grandeur.
allen@home almost 4 years ago
Be careful Bleeb if the guy suddenly leans back you could get squashed.
Liverlips McCracken Premium Member almost 4 years ago
Aahh, the Thanksgiving diet. Stuff “healthy.” Yeah I want another piece of pie!
Boots at the Boar Premium Member almost 4 years ago
Technically pumpkin is a fruit, but so are tomatoes, which I can’t accept.
Farside99 almost 4 years ago
I’m not buying it. A pumpkin is a fruit.
nosirrom almost 4 years ago
Carrot cake is another option.
buflogal! almost 4 years ago
It also has milk and eggs. With the crust it’s a full meal.
Ralph Newbill almost 4 years ago
Exactly! And fruit, lots of cherry, blueberry, and apple pie. And don’t forget the protein in the pecan pie!
bryce.gear almost 4 years ago
Uhh, isn’t pumpkin a fruit?
pathamil almost 4 years ago
The red and green wrapped Holiday Hershey Kisses count as vegetables, too…
geese28 almost 4 years ago
Pumpkin pie, pumpkin spice, pumpkin bread. See? Veggie intake solved
Amra Leo almost 4 years ago
Well, share! Bleeb wants some…
Nyckname almost 4 years ago
“Cake for breakfast!”
vaughnrl2003 Premium Member almost 4 years ago
Okay, I’m going to use that. I will get my dairy for the day in whipped cream and protein with pecans. If you’ve never had pumpkin pie with pecans and whipped cream, you should.
Bob Blumenfeld almost 4 years ago
Anybody want to point out that pumpkins are vegetables?
DavidPlatt almost 4 years ago
Here we can cite Nix vs. Hedden, the 1893 case in which the Supreme Court ruled that the tomato is botanically a fruit, and legally a vegetable for the purposes of taxation. The reasoning is that it’s usually used (in cooking) in the same way as other vegetables – it’s eaten as part of a meal, and not as a sweet dessert after the meal as fruits usually are.
The same reasoning applies to squash in general, cucumbers, chayote, green beans, avocados, and olives… botanically fruits, but eaten as vegetables.
Pumpkin pie is an odd case. The pumpkin is botanically a fruit, and not particularly sweet. Cook it up as soup or in a “Three Sisters” Native American stew, and it’s a vegetable. Take that same pumpkin, chop it up, mix with eggs and pour it into a crust and bake it, and it’s pumpkin quiche… still eaten as part of the meal, and it’s still a vegetable.
Puree it as you would for a soup, add sugar and milk and nutmeg and maybe an egg, pour and bake it in the very same crust as the quiche, and it’s pumpkin pie… a dessert, and suddenly pumpkin is back to being a fruit.
… unless pumpkin pie and salad is all you eat at that meal, in which case you’re eating sweet quiche instead of pie-for-dessert, so it’s a vegetable again.
… or unless you put tomato catsup on it, which (according to the Reagan administration) counts as a vegetable.
… or if you put pumpkin pie on your cottage cheese, substituting it for the tomato catsup that President Nixon used to use, and thus making it vegetable-by-analogy.
I hope that all is very clear now. I’ll go have some watermelon now… clearly a vegetable since it’s just a cucumber with pretensions of grandeur.
Dobie Premium Member almost 4 years ago
“Honey, umm you appear to be smashing a little yellow alien bug looking thing in your chair… it looks like it’s trying to say sump’n… listen!”
“ᖘ꒒ꏂꏂ꓄ꀍ ꁅꏂ꓄ ꂦꎇꎇ ꎭꏂ!
ꌩꂦꀎ’ꋪꏂ ꌚꎭꍏ꓄ꀍꀤꈤꁅ ꎭꏂ“
“Oh sorry, I didn’t see it there when I sat down to eat my third piece of pie. What do you think it said?”
“Well… … it was hard to tell, but it sounded sorta like: “lay off the pie, porky!”
BoSundling almost 4 years ago
Technically, pumpkin is a fruit. Just saying…
e.groves almost 4 years ago
Watch out for “Pumpkin Piarhea.”
jbduncan almost 4 years ago
Pumpkin pie goes well with turkey pot pie.
cuzinron47 almost 4 years ago
Bleeb’s in a bit of a tight squeeze.
paranormal almost 4 years ago
He shoulda had Carrot Cake…
scpandich almost 4 years ago
Thrown about yesterday, squashed today, Bleeb’s been having a rough time of it the last few days.