I saw a great cartoon a few years ago. Four panels, the first two were labelled “over” and “under” and showed toilet paper mounted that way. The third said “sideways”, with the roll on end, standing on the little rod. The fourth had no paper at all and was labelled “kids”
Let’s look at it from a pure ergonomics perspective. When it is over it is a few inches or more depending on the size of the Roll closer to you. Thus every time you grab some paper from an over roll you are expanding less energy than an under roll. End of story!
I’m surprised the Overs even made it to the corner without slimming down. Or perhaps they were an advance party of the Unders who stopped and flipped their faces?
If it is on a spindle that sticks out from the wall, it should be ‘over’, so that you can easily find the end, and easily pull it out. If it is on a spindle that swings out from the wall, and you have it ‘over’, it will jam against the wall when you pull on it. If it is ‘under’, even though you can’t see the end, you can use you finger tips to make it feed off the back (per Archie Bunker). So, it depends on the type of spindle you have. UNLESS!! you have a cat, and in the first situation it is very easy for the cat to unwind the whole roll. In this exception, if you reverse it, then it will bind against the wall, and thwart the playful kitty!
rebeccabyram22 over 5 years ago
Unders
enigmamz over 5 years ago
One push backwards and the Under will simply start to unravel!
KA7DRE Premium Member over 5 years ago
It will be a battle to the finish !
Superfrog over 5 years ago
It’ll be a tearable struggle and it won’t be over until the paperwork is done.
Arianne over 5 years ago
Go, man, go,
But not like a yoyo schoolboy.
Just play it cool, boy,
Real cool.
blunebottle over 5 years ago
Excellent gag! Could have made it more interesting with male on the left, female on the right.
juncarlo over 5 years ago
It does not matter who wins, they all end up smeared with…sh…
Bryan Farht over 5 years ago
I vote for the butt shower!
jbrobo Premium Member over 5 years ago
They wiped each other out…
Say What Now‽ Premium Member over 5 years ago
Over, if you don’t have a cat who could be a problem.
SusanSunshine Premium Member over 5 years ago
Hard to guess who’ll win…
they’ve both been on a roll lately.
I wish they would all just hang around, each someplace where they’re appreciated,
instead of having to square off.
But their backs are to the wall….
each side is determined to go only one way.Cos that’s the way they roll… loyal right down to the core.
Skeptical Meg over 5 years ago
I saw a great cartoon a few years ago. Four panels, the first two were labelled “over” and “under” and showed toilet paper mounted that way. The third said “sideways”, with the roll on end, standing on the little rod. The fourth had no paper at all and was labelled “kids”
DanFlak over 5 years ago
According to the patent filed for toilet paper, over is what is presented.
Plods with ...™ over 5 years ago
Over.
We’ve had that discussion here and we’re in agreement. She said.
Stocky One over 5 years ago
There’s going to be a battle Royale…
danholt over 5 years ago
There’s gonna be a rumble tonight…
SkyFisher over 5 years ago
Next round: Single or two-ply!
Nuliajuk over 5 years ago
What’s the over-under if I want to place a bet?
n4hhe over 5 years ago
The overs do not stand a chance with a cat.
anomalous4 over 5 years ago
“Over, under, sideways, down, / Backwards, forwards, square & round, / When will it end…”
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L4DdAs0PddQ
Indianapolis Smith over 5 years ago
They all look rough and tough to me. I’m not using any of ’em.
John9 over 5 years ago
This is only my opinion, I don’t care as long as it is there.
dsidney49 over 5 years ago
Overs… that’s how I “roll”…
NaturLvr over 5 years ago
Over is easier to grab and it keeps fingers/fingernails away from the wall or back of the holder, if you have a recessed one.
Stupid over 5 years ago
Nuts to that: OVER all the way. Doesn’t get stuck!
noktar Premium Member over 5 years ago
I prefer over
coffeemom88 over 5 years ago
Now if there’s a thunderstorm, there will be zero winners … just a lumpy mass of wood pulp . . LOL
vorlon42 over 5 years ago
In the end, it was a wipeout.
Leojim over 5 years ago
Let’s look at it from a pure ergonomics perspective. When it is over it is a few inches or more depending on the size of the Roll closer to you. Thus every time you grab some paper from an over roll you are expanding less energy than an under roll. End of story!
ChukLitl Premium Member over 5 years ago
Either way goes over the top to hang down. You should say front or back. As others have noted, with cats or toddlers around go with back.
1craftylady over 5 years ago
Ah, so the neverending battle continues…
Bozo T over 5 years ago
I’m surprised the Overs even made it to the corner without slimming down. Or perhaps they were an advance party of the Unders who stopped and flipped their faces?
WCraft Premium Member over 5 years ago
At least you didn’t add further controversy by making one side blue and the other side red…
whelan_jj over 5 years ago
Over is easier to use but under is necessary if you have young kids or pets who like to unroll.
Impkins Premium Member over 5 years ago
I can’t seem to get the surfing tune Wipe Out out of my head!! :>)
b95954297b48a54fcff8fddbcdef6b2f over 5 years ago
As long as it the job done, I don’t care anymore.
Ka`ōnōhi`ula`okahōkūmiomio`ehiku Premium Member over 5 years ago
What a sh!tty subject for a cartoon!
Hippogriff over 5 years ago
Soft enough to avoid abrasions and firm enough not to leave cellulose suppositories.
STACEY MARSHALL Premium Member over 5 years ago
If it is on a spindle that sticks out from the wall, it should be ‘over’, so that you can easily find the end, and easily pull it out. If it is on a spindle that swings out from the wall, and you have it ‘over’, it will jam against the wall when you pull on it. If it is ‘under’, even though you can’t see the end, you can use you finger tips to make it feed off the back (per Archie Bunker). So, it depends on the type of spindle you have. UNLESS!! you have a cat, and in the first situation it is very easy for the cat to unwind the whole roll. In this exception, if you reverse it, then it will bind against the wall, and thwart the playful kitty!
Stephen Gilberg over 5 years ago
First World problems.
Daeder over 5 years ago
Who’s taking bets? What’s the over/under?
paullp Premium Member over 5 years ago
Their numbers seem evenly matched, unless one side can persuade a few members of the other side to flip.
Earthling Premium Member over 5 years ago
Don’t make me come over there!
decalwrites over 5 years ago
https://www.businessinsider.com/patent-shows-right-way-to-hang-toilet-paper-2015-3
RetFor over 5 years ago
The over-ies or the und-ies
Cameron1988 Premium Member over 5 years ago
Over. Definitely over
Mary Sullivan Premium Member over 5 years ago
I don’t actually mind either way, but here it looks like the unders may trip on their tails.
zeexenon over 5 years ago
Overs, obviously to the most casual observing mathematician.