I know how we can find out! The other saying of “If a man is talking but there’s no-one there to hear him, is he still wrong?” can be used. Whatever he says the the answer about the tree making a noise is, the opposite must be correct! ☺
The correct saying is, “If a tree falls and there’s no one there to hear it, does it make a NOISE?” (The answer is no, because NOISE is a subjective term.)
Either the tree fell on its own or the men are incredibly incompetent lumberjacks. Just take a look at the condition of the stump and the bottom of the fallen tree.
wiatr about 5 years ago
Her opinion would not count as she was obviously there. Aside from that I doubt her opinion will come in a form you wish to process. Run!
stillfickled Premium Member about 5 years ago
but there were people around
The Reader Premium Member about 5 years ago
And that’s why they put up ‘No Texting’ signs in the forest.
jagedlo about 5 years ago
a couple of guys are about to be zapped!
Janet Gamble Premium Member about 5 years ago
Yes! But you may have to censor the witness!
scottartist creator about 5 years ago
So Broomie is nobody…
Zebrastripes about 5 years ago
BROOMY must have been flying under the radar again….
ChukLitl Premium Member about 5 years ago
Does reality care whether there’s an observer?
ChessPirate about 5 years ago
I know how we can find out! The other saying of “If a man is talking but there’s no-one there to hear him, is he still wrong?” can be used. Whatever he says the the answer about the tree making a noise is, the opposite must be correct! ☺
r.c.e about 5 years ago
Does a bear (bleep) in the woods?
cuzinron47 about 5 years ago
For sure she made a sound, and you’re probably gonna hear some more.
ucomicsrwd Premium Member about 5 years ago
The correct saying is, “If a tree falls and there’s no one there to hear it, does it make a NOISE?” (The answer is no, because NOISE is a subjective term.)
redback about 5 years ago
I am sure Broomie heard a sound, but instead of a ‘crash’ it was more like a ‘ftphhfff’. It had padding; which is why other people didn’t hear it
fix-n-fly about 5 years ago
Careful – you could get zapped!
Billy Yank about 5 years ago
Either the tree fell on its own or the men are incredibly incompetent lumberjacks. Just take a look at the condition of the stump and the bottom of the fallen tree.
cubswin2016 about 5 years ago
It would not make a sound if no one is around to hear it. Sound is the interpretation of sound waves and you need a person for that.
gammaguy about 5 years ago
If someone posts a video but it doesn’t go viral, does it really exist?
cybergal29 about 5 years ago
A BIG ZAP coming in 3 … 2 … 1!
craigwestlake about 5 years ago
No matter where it falls there will be a lawyer to hear it…
Sisyphos about 5 years ago
Flattened Broomie looks none too happy. Beware, lumberjacks! It’s not okay!