I remember the candy ratings from my long-ago trick-or-treating. About midway down was the peanut butter saltwater taffy (in orange or black wrappers), then the rolls of things that looked like Sweetarts but were flavorless sugar, finally to cellophane packs of blue-gray sugar pills.
I think I was about 7 or 8 when I started doing that but with a twist. I put all the candy that I did not like in a Tupperware container to give out the next year.
In my large family, some kids wanted to eat the good stuff first, some wanted to save and savor it, and my youngest brother just ate until throwing up, the first year he was allowed to make his own choice. I kind of averaged: A few of the uninteresting and a good one or two… ending with the good one so I had that taste in my mouth afterward.
My strategy is. To eat the gross stuff first, then eat all the good stuff until the next Halloween, when I fill up my pumpkin with even more candy, which I get more than I would’ve if I had eaten all my candy, and keep doing so until I need a pillowcase for all my candy.
Sugar Bombs 95 about 5 years ago
What I would do as a kid is trade the candy I don’t like to people who DO like that candy in favor of candy I DO like.
codycab about 5 years ago
So Phoebe has already eaten the “chuckle’s”, “Mix” and “Creamyroad”? She keeps this up and she could beat Pinkie Pie in an eating contest.
Dirty Dragon about 5 years ago
(Don’t eat the pennies, kid.)
Antiyonder about 5 years ago
So I’m guessing Phoebe’s neighborhood lacks a considerate soul who includes a free Halloween comic with candy. Deplorable!
Yeah I hit the comic store prior to Halloween myself to get those HCF titles before the 31st.
Averagemoe about 5 years ago
Dang, I usually don’t reach that state until mid-December.
222jo about 5 years ago
Eat the worst first…
PoodleGroomer about 5 years ago
What is the difference between granola bars and unicorn food? Desperation.
Aladar30 Premium Member about 5 years ago
Phoebe must do it the reverse, or eat her favorite candy and her avoiding two at a time at the same time.
docforbin about 5 years ago
Phoebe’s predicament kind of reminds me of Linus’ one in this classic Peanuts strip: https://www.gocomics.com/peanuts/1963/12/08
rpmurray about 5 years ago
“What if you did not eat all the candy?” That’s crazy talk.
Happy, happy, happy!!! Premium Member about 5 years ago
Gotta get that sugar fix! :D
Vince M about 5 years ago
I remember the candy ratings from my long-ago trick-or-treating. About midway down was the peanut butter saltwater taffy (in orange or black wrappers), then the rolls of things that looked like Sweetarts but were flavorless sugar, finally to cellophane packs of blue-gray sugar pills.
scyphi26 about 5 years ago
You’re just talking nonsense, Marigold.
Mark Beckett about 5 years ago
“Too caramel-y” is not a thing.
Neo Stryder about 5 years ago
And a long stomachache too.
Godfreydaniel about 5 years ago
I used to toss out my candy corn for the birds and the squirrels—and they never DID forgive me!
NoLongerWandering about 5 years ago
You always eat the candy you don’t like. That’s how you find out you liked it all along!
Stephen Gilberg about 5 years ago
I prefer to mix it up and never eat more than two of the same type of candy in a row. Give it a sort of rhythm.
Teto85 Premium Member about 5 years ago
I think I was about 7 or 8 when I started doing that but with a twist. I put all the candy that I did not like in a Tupperware container to give out the next year.
DDrazen about 5 years ago
I’d never eat coconut candy under any circumstances.
bookworm0812 about 5 years ago
I’ll take the coconutty stuff!
Concretionist about 5 years ago
In my large family, some kids wanted to eat the good stuff first, some wanted to save and savor it, and my youngest brother just ate until throwing up, the first year he was allowed to make his own choice. I kind of averaged: A few of the uninteresting and a good one or two… ending with the good one so I had that taste in my mouth afterward.
Daeder about 5 years ago
What about “too waxy”? Yes, yes I am talking about candy corn.
neatslob Premium Member about 5 years ago
Too chalky would be the Necco wafers.
asrialfeeple about 5 years ago
I find your taste changes over the years. Things I could live on I can’t stand now.
The Ever-Convenient Object's Shopping Mall about 5 years ago
‘too caramel-y’? WHAT THE HECK DOES THAT MEAN?!?
LrdSlvrhnd about 5 years ago
Too… caramel-y? does not compute
Josequeen almost 4 years ago
My strategy is. To eat the gross stuff first, then eat all the good stuff until the next Halloween, when I fill up my pumpkin with even more candy, which I get more than I would’ve if I had eaten all my candy, and keep doing so until I need a pillowcase for all my candy.
Kark_The_Red_Canadian_Dragon 7 months ago
She’s gone through all of her candy ALREADY??? You’d think she’d have enough candy to last her a MONTH, at least… :/