I had no problems with the movie; the book? 40-some pages in and I surrendered. I did read a Dostoyevsky book and that took me a year. The periods of things happening were spread apart by long dissertations on Man’s relationships with his God and his soul.
So “many characters” means I’d have trouble with the movie. I have prosopagnosia. Watching at home, I often pause a movie to ask me SO, “is that the same guy from the previous scene?” or something like that. I’m hell in a theater!
the problem with trying to read war and peace is that after five minutes or so your fingers start to go numb from the effort of trying to grip the thick tome. you definitely don’t want to read it before bed because when you inevitably fall asleep in the midst of reading you’ll end up with a concussion when the book smacks you in the forehead…
Nor did most of us who saw the movie. However, books offer so much more than movies can. How many of the Harry Potter fans out there who read a combined 3500 pages or more of reading the seven novels, taking multiple dozens of hours, can honestly say the movies were better than the books. While I enjoyed both, the books allowed me to actually share the journeys and exploits as if I were actually there. I must confess that I have not read War and Peace, but it is on my Bucket List. If you liked the movie, the novel will usually make the experience better. Give it a shot Brutus……
A high school English teacher had War and Peace on his recommended summer reading list. During the last week of school he did brief summaries of why we might find certain books interesting. When I saw the size of that book I thought, “No way! I want time to do others things this summer.” And that’s, from someone who would read almost anything and everything.
Unfortunately, as I’ve gotten older, I’ve found it more difficult to follow the plots of books or TV shows that have lots of characters. I’m watching a Brit series right now, and they have quite a few people I have to try to remember. The good thing about it is, at the end, they tie everything together, so I keep watching because it’s so good.
I always find Russian literature confusing because everyone has three different names depending on who is addressing them. Since there also are a lot of characters, you can be trying to keep track of dozens of names.
A popular 20th century author (I think it was Heinlein) said of Russian literature…Paraphrasing here…“The Brothers Karamazov was dark, depressing, brooding and difficult to read. Perhaps it was a poor translation, so I read the original language version. It was worse.”
Books like War and Peace and other Russian epics are the only things I’ve read that are more palatable as movies. In English.
When all else fails, watch Love & Death https://youtu.be/ELI212NgR6M?t=211
dadthedawg Premium Member over 3 years ago
He even slept through part of it…..
Renatus Profuturus Frigeridus Premium Member over 3 years ago
It is true that Russian literature is full of characters: like Russian music has lot of notes and instruments.
LookingGlass Premium Member over 3 years ago
Meh!! You see one war movie and you’ve seen them all!! Boom-Boom, bang-bang, etc etc!! In the end, it get’s monotonous!!" *ZZZZZZZZZZZ
(- _ -)
wiatr over 3 years ago
I had no problems with the movie; the book? 40-some pages in and I surrendered. I did read a Dostoyevsky book and that took me a year. The periods of things happening were spread apart by long dissertations on Man’s relationships with his God and his soul.
wjones over 3 years ago
It can take a long time to read the book, you know you will fall asleep before your done.
pauljmsn over 3 years ago
I read the book as a teenager. I think it was abridged, but still several hundred pages long.
I remember it’s about Russia.
GROG Premium Member over 3 years ago
I think the movie left out a thing or two.
jmworacle over 3 years ago
Best sleep he had in a long while.
Baarorso over 3 years ago
I’ve read classic literature before. To me it’s often a slog to get through with prose that is VERY flowery and descriptive.
Skeptical Meg over 3 years ago
So “many characters” means I’d have trouble with the movie. I have prosopagnosia. Watching at home, I often pause a movie to ask me SO, “is that the same guy from the previous scene?” or something like that. I’m hell in a theater!
Jeff0811 over 3 years ago
Speaking of characters, Uncle Ted is my favorite. He has achieved what I for now can only aspire to, retirement. :^)
Larrycleve over 3 years ago
I guess Uncle Ted visits like Mother Gargle? I’ve never seen them there together.
Chris over 3 years ago
gee, I wonder why.
gopher gofer over 3 years ago
the problem with trying to read war and peace is that after five minutes or so your fingers start to go numb from the effort of trying to grip the thick tome. you definitely don’t want to read it before bed because when you inevitably fall asleep in the midst of reading you’ll end up with a concussion when the book smacks you in the forehead…
Michael G. over 3 years ago
A most effective soporific.
saltylife16 over 3 years ago
Brutus, that’s a no no. Don’t interrupt a retired person finally doing what they always wanted to do. Especially Uncle Ted.
bigplayray over 3 years ago
Original tittle… “War. What is it good for?”
Brent Rosenthal Premium Member over 3 years ago
Halfway through the book I realized I should have kept a notepad with the characters listed. All the ‘ovitches got me lost!
comixbomix over 3 years ago
It’s because you were using all 3% of your brain’s capabilities…weren’t you listening when Veeblefester explained it to you yesterday?
raybarb44 over 3 years ago
Nor did most of us who saw the movie. However, books offer so much more than movies can. How many of the Harry Potter fans out there who read a combined 3500 pages or more of reading the seven novels, taking multiple dozens of hours, can honestly say the movies were better than the books. While I enjoyed both, the books allowed me to actually share the journeys and exploits as if I were actually there. I must confess that I have not read War and Peace, but it is on my Bucket List. If you liked the movie, the novel will usually make the experience better. Give it a shot Brutus……
paranormal over 3 years ago
You slept thru most of it…
heathcliff2 over 3 years ago
I hear the real story was much more involved.
l3i7l over 3 years ago
A high school English teacher had War and Peace on his recommended summer reading list. During the last week of school he did brief summaries of why we might find certain books interesting. When I saw the size of that book I thought, “No way! I want time to do others things this summer.” And that’s, from someone who would read almost anything and everything.
Buckeye67 over 3 years ago
You got me beat Brutus, I haven’t even seen the movie.
dv1093 over 3 years ago
I started to read War and Peace once. Once.
Lola85 Premium Member over 3 years ago
Unfortunately, as I’ve gotten older, I’ve found it more difficult to follow the plots of books or TV shows that have lots of characters. I’m watching a Brit series right now, and they have quite a few people I have to try to remember. The good thing about it is, at the end, they tie everything together, so I keep watching because it’s so good.
mistercatworks over 3 years ago
I always find Russian literature confusing because everyone has three different names depending on who is addressing them. Since there also are a lot of characters, you can be trying to keep track of dozens of names.
Gordo4ever over 3 years ago
Je suis Brutus on some days, je suis Uncle Ted on others. Need more “Uncle Ted Days”. : )
Andylit Premium Member over 3 years ago
A popular 20th century author (I think it was Heinlein) said of Russian literature…Paraphrasing here…“The Brothers Karamazov was dark, depressing, brooding and difficult to read. Perhaps it was a poor translation, so I read the original language version. It was worse.”
Books like War and Peace and other Russian epics are the only things I’ve read that are more palatable as movies. In English.
When all else fails, watch Love & Death https://youtu.be/ELI212NgR6M?t=211
christelisbetty over 3 years ago
That book doesn’t look thick enough. Now that my foot is in the door, what do the Thornapples think about thr Cleveland Guardians ?
oakie817 over 3 years ago
read everything as a kid…read ‘war and peace’ in the 5th grade and loved it, and it wasn’t a class assignment
No New Wars almost 2 years ago
War and Pace, summarised: the army marched forward. The army marched back.