If a man is speaking the forest, and there is no woman around to hear him, is he still wrong? My sister’s reply was, “What a silly question: of course he is!”
What’s next, the one about an irresistible force and an immovable object? I think it was Isaac Asimov who wrote that he impressed a girl by explaining that particular conundrum. His solution was that the two things couldn’t possibly exist in the same universe.
Liverlips McCracken Premium Member about 4 years ago
Of course it makes a sound. Why discount all the other living things around the tree other than humans?
Qiset about 4 years ago
It’s all in your mind.
david_42 about 4 years ago
In his case, I think the shock waves go in one ear, bypass what he uses to help him walk, and out the other ear.
unfair.de about 4 years ago
Toby pretending to be a philosopher is like seeing American billionaires using all their wealth to help rebuild the US economy after Trump.
Will happen only if they’re wrestled to it by their creator. Unfortunately billionaires are less likely to be made doing that by their creator.
Michael G. about 4 years ago
Sound can’t pass through the vacuum hovering over his shoulders …
Ed The Red Premium Member about 4 years ago
It makes a sound, but does not make a noise.
John Wiley Premium Member about 4 years ago
It’s just pressure waves travelling through the air until your ears perceive it as sound, or noise cancelling headphones don’t actually work.
Longplay Premium Member about 4 years ago
That’s the best explanation to that conundrum I’ve seen, or heard for that matter.
bobbyferrel about 4 years ago
Go ask Heisenberg.
Doctor Toon about 4 years ago
If a tree falls in the forest and there is no living thing to experience the sound or vibrations, then my guess is that the planet is dead
ChessPirate about 4 years ago
If some sort of recording device is operating near where the tree falls and then played back later, I’d put money on there being a sound on it… ☺
cuzinron47 about 4 years ago
Depends on whether mute button is on.
Marvin Premium Member about 4 years ago
Why doesn’t she dump that dummy?
STACEY MARSHALL Premium Member about 4 years ago
If a man is speaking the forest, and there is no woman around to hear him, is he still wrong? My sister’s reply was, “What a silly question: of course he is!”
paullp Premium Member about 4 years ago
What’s next, the one about an irresistible force and an immovable object? I think it was Isaac Asimov who wrote that he impressed a girl by explaining that particular conundrum. His solution was that the two things couldn’t possibly exist in the same universe.
whelan_jj about 4 years ago
If a tree falls in a forest and there is no one to see it does it really fall?
If dinosaurs lived before there were any humans did they really exist?