Forget stamping of feet and repeating the question. Simply point out that the original question is insufficiently defined and bounded to produce a meaningful answer. The only suitable answer is another question or a series of them, beginning with “Why what?” Other responses might include: “How would you like that question to be interpreted and defined in order to produce a fitting answer?” — as well as reiterating what was said yesterday or the day before to the effect that this question is not qualified to be a “riddle”.
codycab about 1 year ago
Then try, “How come?” Happy Thanksgiving!
Averagemoe about 1 year ago
Is Stella testing Maaaaow, or is Maaaaow providing Stella’s material?
Concretionist about 1 year ago
I vote “Macrame” … or knot…
Antiyonder about 1 year ago
So in a twist, maybe the answer is Turkey?XD
Masterius about 1 year ago
“Why?”…
Because.
Eala Dubh Sidhe about 1 year ago
Wait, I know this one, it’s ‘giant 60s computer spins tape reels really fast and explodes’.
Calvinist1966 about 1 year ago
Phoebe isn’t actually helping. She’s just trying to help and is being trying instead.
mistie710 about 1 year ago
42?
Decepticomic about 1 year ago
Because membership is low, and they gotta get those numbers UP!
ProclaimLiberty about 1 year ago
Forget stamping of feet and repeating the question. Simply point out that the original question is insufficiently defined and bounded to produce a meaningful answer. The only suitable answer is another question or a series of them, beginning with “Why what?” Other responses might include: “How would you like that question to be interpreted and defined in order to produce a fitting answer?” — as well as reiterating what was said yesterday or the day before to the effect that this question is not qualified to be a “riddle”.
Neo Stryder about 1 year ago
The answer for Why? is Because… or Mantech, is always Mantech
DaBump Premium Member about 1 year ago
Why not? is a good start, but doubling down indeed is not.
Tallguy about 1 year ago
You know asking “Why” helped Number Six blow up a computer.
Steverino Premium Member about 1 year ago
What is the airspeed velocity of an unladen swallow?
French Persons Premium Member almost 1 year ago
Sorry Phoebe, that doesn’t work on me either.
Ermine Notyours almost 1 year ago
No, WHYY are a public radio and television stations.
puddleglum1066 almost 1 year ago
If “Why not?” was good enough for Kurt Vonnegut, it’s good enough for you, sphinx.
Twelve Badgers in a Suit Premium Member almost 1 year ago
I think “Why not?” is a pretty good answer. But, I bet the answer the sphinx is expecting is completely non-verbal.
Ken Norris Premium Member almost 1 year ago
Because I SAID SO!!!
Simple is as simple does…
Hello Sweetie almost 1 year ago
According to my mom the answer is, “Because I say so and I’m your mother.”
Aladar30 Premium Member almost 1 year ago
Phoebe and Marigold should leave the Sphinx/cat free to make mistakes on they own.
Wlly Blly almost 1 year ago
The correct answer to “why”, is “because”.
Fluffy_and_Mervin almost 1 year ago
Because.
neatslob Premium Member 12 months ago
Everyone who has been a child knows the correct answer is “Because I said so.”