For Better or For Worse by Lynn Johnston for May 18, 2010

  1. Lady with a bow
    ejcapulet  over 14 years ago

    Oh boy, was that a stupid thing to say! I hope he has a thoughtful, heartfelt reason (like “I was worried”).

     •  Reply
  2. 2011 0615 1745.seamus
    sarge112751  over 14 years ago

    you have the right to REMAIN SILENT and I suggest you USE it … NOW!

    Any time a man gets the LAST word in an argument, he can rest assured, it’ll actually be the FIRST word in the NEXT argument!

     •  Reply
  3. Uncavatar
    CarolinaGirl  over 14 years ago

    Stupid AND typical

     •  Reply
  4. Large pumpkin in window
    Dkram  over 14 years ago

    I think I just heard that a little while ago. (ha ha)

    \\//_

     •  Reply
  5. Missing large
    Artrina  over 14 years ago

    He had better learn to keep his mouth shut - and soon! He seems to be chomping on it in a BIG way every couple of months. I hope Ellie puts her foot down the next time HE wants to go out with the boys for an evening!

     •  Reply
  6. Dscn7190 small
    stuart  over 14 years ago

    I took it as a joke. Of course, people often don’t react well to my jokes either.

     •  Reply
  7. Scooby doo
    diodonofrio  over 14 years ago

    I think she’s about to smash that $2000 stereo he just bought. And maybe stick her manual can opener up his…..nose!

     •  Reply
  8. Beatnik 128x128
    ocean17  over 14 years ago

    Elly to self in frame 4: “Yes, yes, you DID marry this dweeb.”

    John to self: “Ha, got her that time. All this and a dentist too! I’m the bomb!”

     •  Reply
  9. Large dolphin1a
    DolphinGirl78  over 14 years ago

    How little trust he has…

     •  Reply
  10. What has been seen t1
    lewisbower  over 14 years ago

    Panel 3 “I’m glad you girls had a good time. Hope you can do it again soon.” Hope you’re a good poker player.

     •  Reply
  11. Avatar
    Mythreesons  over 14 years ago

    Add “It’s just that I miss you so much when you aren’t here with me.” That should open the doghouse door.

     •  Reply
  12. Ngc891 rs 580x527
    alan.gurka  over 14 years ago

    Ah, but does he really?

     •  Reply
  13. 85687b49dadc69f9a2841bdc1f655d095832d649 hq
    gaebie  over 14 years ago

    What’s wrong about his comment? Makes sense to me.

     •  Reply
  14. Images
    Sugie63  over 14 years ago

    HAH! He’s a man so he’a a control freak.

     •  Reply
  15. Whatwouldblue
    mrslukeskywalker  over 14 years ago

    Yup, I called it!

    I’m glad Elly finally stuck up for herself instead of throwing the usual fit.

    Psychobabble it all you want to, this is the way men think. It’s the way they always were, and the way they still are, even though these days, some of them may less inclined to admit it. It’s the primal nature of the beast. I don’t care what anyone says to the contrary (which is coming, since it always does.), That’s the truth. There are shelves full of books in the stores, because as simple as men really are to understand, women don’t want to see it, so they say it isn’t so, and live with the consequences of doing so, then end up on talk shows complaining about it.

    He knew where she was, he told Michael. He just didn’t like it, because he wasn’t in control of her. This is a man who gives his wife work appliances as gifts. She is effectively chattel in the back of his man mind. We’ve seen it consistently. Repeat chorus #2.

    Elly wins today, and she did it without screaming. Bravo, until tomorrow.

    ~Note~ I am not bashing men. They can’t help the way nature wired them.

     •  Reply
  16. Missing large
    puddleglum1066  over 14 years ago

    I have noted a kind of gender-based double standard on the issue of “reporting in.” Women (and in my experience this begins with the mother and continues with the wife) expect to be told where the man is and when he plans to be home, and there will be consequences if the man fails to file his flight plan. On the other hand, while they don’t do it as often, women seem to expect that they can disappear for the evening without phoning home, and face no consequences come morning.

    I suspect this has to do with stereotyping: when the man is “off leash,” there seems to be the assumption he is up to no good; e.g., drinking himself blind and/or cheating on his spouse. Meanwhile, the stereotypical woman, should she disappear for the evening, is probably at a sewing circle or a church meeting; definitely not doing anything dangerous or unsavory (oh yeah? and just who are all those men cheating with, anyway?).

    Judging by the number of commenters taking Elly’s side in this dispute, I suspect FBoFW’s online readership is overwhelmingly female…

    (Let the bashing begin…)

     •  Reply
  17. Small tower
    RadioTom  over 14 years ago

    I vote for worried sick spouse/parent. John’s fatherhood is coming out… And yes, I know Elly’s his WIFE, not his daughter; but from a loving male’s perspective, the two are very similar.

    BTDT, in fact. I never knew which one I worried about more - wife or daughter. Even today, with wife an Ex, and Daughter clear across the country… and Daughter 32 yo at that… I still worry.

     •  Reply
  18. Silverknights
    JanLC  over 14 years ago

    Mrs Luke: Well said.

    Radio Tom: I know when I stay away longer than I anticipated, I try to let my husband know I’m OK. I’m not checking in (so the feminists can relax), I’m just trying to ease the mind of the man I love. He does have a tendency to worry.

     •  Reply
  19. J0262810
    Wildmustang1262  over 14 years ago

    Oh John! You better keep your mouth shaddup and make a silent for a while. Let Elly have good time for once in her lifetime! Apparently, John is a worrywart!

    LOLs! I love the way Elly showed her “facial expression” while John spilled out of his mouth about knowing where she is.

     •  Reply
  20. Beehive
    poohbear8192  over 14 years ago

    From the outside looking in, I think John’s an idiot.

    From inside me, I would probably feel the same way and say the same unfortunate thing.

    The learning curve is often ahead of good sense.

    Good luck John. You are going to need it!

     •  Reply
  21. Warthog
    wndrwrthg  over 14 years ago

    John has every right to be concerned that she went bar hopping without letting him know. The only reason she did not, was that she was up to no good. Women can’t help that they lie and cheat, that’s how nature wired them.

     •  Reply
  22. Cathyfacepalm
    gobblingup Premium Member over 14 years ago

    What’s good for the goose is good for the gander.

    @wndrwrthg – I’m guessing you’re single.

     •  Reply
  23. Missing large
    jeffreybradmc  over 14 years ago

    What is love, love is caring, love is trusting, love is concerning and love controling, but when done properly, it’s NOT overly demanding.

     •  Reply
  24. Missing large
    KatalinaDuBois  over 14 years ago

    Wow..gotta love how a strip can bring out the true thinking of some people. Bashing and such. And no..this is not aimed at any one person.

    Ok… here’s my take. I come from an abusive background, so automatically, I saw John as being a control freak, and of course hypocritical.

    However, there are two Sides to Every story, that being said, I have to take into account that Elly didn’t really tell John, at least..not that I know of. Well More to the point, she didn’t Ask him, like he asked her.

    Never mind how she felt when he went….the point is He asked, She said Yes.

    She could have asked, and the outcome would be different.

    I digress….

    So after looking at both sides. I think that John was really worried about her. Back then, women were seen as needing protection. And sometimes are still seen that way.

    For all of her faults, John loves Elly, and like most of us who loves someone, we put the Worst scenario into our minds when we’re confronted with the unknown.

    Now, when My boyfriend goes out, be it to his friend’s house, or to his mom, or even cross country to see his dad, Guess what? The worst case scenario goes through my mind. always. But in the end, I trust him, and i know he’s ok.

    He goes through the same with me. :) So, my point after this TL;DR is that I believe John was really worried, and well lets face it…

    Most [not all. i HATE blanket groupings] Most men do not know how, or are capable of sharing there feelings…for Most men it’s a Learned thing,

    And most Women [again, not All] are wired to be fairly high strung and emotional. As such we tend to react stronger to things. And some better than others. [again..Most..not ALL]

    Elly and John simply need to learn how to communicate better. And take each others quirks in stride.

    Gah.

    So sorry for the thesis here.

     •  Reply
  25. Missing large
    3139lip  over 14 years ago

    Many husbands would think the same thing but know better than to say it, because it would reveal how totally self-centered they are. What makes this cartoon funny is that John actually says what he, and others, are thinking and makes us realize what is going within people – maybe even ourselves.

     •  Reply
  26. Falconchicks1a
    RinaFarina  over 14 years ago

    I don’t see why people are taking offence at what John said. It was totally innocent - and exactly what he was thinking - and only after he said it, might he have considered how it sounded.

    So he knew where she was when he went out? Well, he did! That’s just the relationship they had! So what?

    Neither of them looks in great pain, or very angry - it looks like it’s just a quiet discussion. In fact, rather unlike strips when Ellie screams to high heaven over something. I found it a refreshing change. I remember thinking as I read it, “See? So they can sometimes relate as a normal, reasonable married couple!” Boy, did everybody else disagree with me!

     •  Reply
  27. Crazycat
    LindainOregon  over 14 years ago

    3139lip… I think you nailed it!

     •  Reply
  28. Snoopy   woodstock  hug
    Gretchen's Mom  over 14 years ago

    JanCinVV: I’m with you on that one. I don’t have to “check-in” with my husband regarding my precise-to-the-minute whereabouts because he knows he’s got nothing to worry about regarding my fidelity. But I let him know where I’m going and when I expect to be back so he won’t worry - and wonder! - where I am (and he does the same for me). It’s just common courtesy and a show of respect we have for each other because we’re both worriers. If something were to happen and one of us not only didn’t return home at the expected time but also didn’t call to say there was a change in plans, then the other would have a starting place to begin looking for them (especially if the police end up having to be called. That’s sad to say but that’s just the world we’re now living in these days).

    As I said, it’s just common courtesy and a show of respect for the person you’re married to … especially if you know they’re a worrier.

     •  Reply
  29. Snoopy   woodstock  hug
    Gretchen's Mom  over 14 years ago

    wndrwrthg: GMAB!!!!! I’m guessing you’re a man … and a single one at that!

    Here’s a question for you: Just who is it exactly you think these lying, cheating women are lying and cheating with anyhow???!!! A lying, cheating man, of course!!!!! If anyone is more of a liar and a cheater “by nature” … it’s a man!!! If you don’t believe it, just look at Tiger Woods, Jesse James, Mark Sanford, Eliot Spitzer, Matt Lauer, etc. All these men have perfectly nice wives and they threw their marriages and families away on skanks and tramps because they had highly inflated opinions about themselves and didn’t know how to keep their pants up and zipped!!!!!

     •  Reply
  30. Frinkmeep
    Clobbered by Science Premium Member over 14 years ago

    It’s pretty obvious from the previous days’ strips that John knew she was going out with the people in her class, and he wasn’t WORRIED about her, it BUGGED him that she went out to have fun and left him at home.

    It wasn’t that he didn’t trust her, it wasn’t that he thought she might get hurt or get into trouble (my mom’s “dead in a ditch somewhere” scenario), it was that she went out without him. Yep, he’s got a double standard. Yep, he’s being a bit controlling.

    But I’d say in this case, he doesn’t need to be yelled at for being a pig, he needs someone to gently explain that he should just get the *&#% over himself already. I’m sure as soon as the words in the last panel were out of his mouth, he realized how childish he sounded.

    (Does anyone know if it’s ever been explicitly stated whether the rebooted FBOFW is taking place in the 70s like the original, or is it set in the present day? John’s attitude might not have been so out of place 30 years ago, but now it does come across as whiny. And a 70s setting might explain why she didn’t call to check in - couldn’t find a pay phone, cell phone not an option.)

    Interesting what a Rorschach test this story arc has been for readers’ attitudes towards relationships and the opposite sex. ;)

     •  Reply
  31. Cat asks you to sign a contract
    notinksanymore  over 14 years ago

    I love the fact that because we saw John ask Elly if she minded him going out ONCE that he always does it. That was a planned outing. I find it impossible to believe that he has never gone out with the boys on the spur of the moment.

    My boyfriend an I check in frequently when we are apart. It’s not that we don’t trust each other, it’s that this is a big, sometimes mean world we live in, and stuff happens that no one can predict. It seems the news is constantly full of random shootings in schools and malls, so who can blame him for worrying when I’m away at school or shopping? I take the opposite tack–no news is good news! If something bad happened, I know I will be notified, so I don’t worry if I don’t hear from him.

     •  Reply
  32. Missing large
    1148559  over 14 years ago

    Here’s my take…

    If one member of a couple (man or woman) is going to be home late, they should let their partner know that. It is simple courtesy. No need to go into detail, but to have stayed out without even letting him know that she would be home late was as rude as it would be for him to do the same thing.

    I read John’s statement as concern.

     •  Reply
  33. Canstock3682698
    myming  over 14 years ago

    how true !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    double standard…

     •  Reply
  34. Cathy aack
    lindz.coop Premium Member over 14 years ago

    Agree with everything MrsLuke says today. And it’s because men need to know who their children are so they can support them, protect them and leave all their worldly belongings to them when they die. They do not want to expend valuable resources on someone else’s offspring. So – gotta control “their” women, and we all know women can’t be trusted – right?!

     •  Reply
  35. Cathy aack
    lindz.coop Premium Member over 14 years ago

    Did I miss something? I’m not sure it ever said that John didn’t know where she was?

     •  Reply
  36. Plugger
    ImaPlugger2  over 14 years ago

    Sad, I never see any affection and caring between these two.

     •  Reply
  37. Whatwouldblue
    mrslukeskywalker  over 14 years ago

    Thank you to those who acknowledged my post today. I appreciate that my writing was fairly considered.

    I am trying to be nicer in my comments on this strip, because somehow, some people take what I strictly say about the Pattersons as if I’m talking about them. It isn’t what I ever suggested, and that was not the way I ever intended my comments to be taken.

    I stuck up for John in a couple strips of this this arc too. I just think Elly won the day by handling it the way I wish she did more often, but as we know, she won’t . I don’t think he’s wrong to feel the way he feels.

    I like men. They are my best friends. I am also a woman, who for good reason, won’t put up with guff. I cheer on women, but I also understand men in their trains of thought. I understand them, and I know I have to accept them the way they are. Not saying they are all the same, because they aren’t, just like there are good women, and there are the ones who make us all look bad, once we finally saw what others were talking about when they talked about “those women”. There just happen to be more of “those kinds of men” than “those kinds of women”. I’m saying that several primal basics exist in each (male) man, and some are more in control of themselves than others. One has to decide how much of any person they can happily handle, or not. That goes for men, or women. (The actual saying is something that would get my comment deleted.)

    I don’t think either of them are wrong here. I just think Elly handled the situation correctly. A shock to those who think I never, ever credit her for anything, but I do. I bet she wasn’t home very late either, but I also take into consideration that they are in their late 20’s, or early 30’s (Howtheduck????) in 1980 and 81, which means they were born somewhere around the 50’s, and that they are only acting in the way that was typical of people raised in that era. If you look at today, there are plenty of women and men still being treated (I’ll narrow all the adjectives down to) questionably, but we have really come a long way.

    I won’t say more, because it extends beyond the scope of the strip, and I really do try to stick to just what pertains to the strip.

     •  Reply
  38. Missing large
    RedSteph  over 14 years ago

    I find this thread a very interesting discussion. Throughout the entire arc I perceived John as more worried than controlling. It would have been courteous of Elly to call him to let him know she would be late. His comment about knowing where she is struck me as protective, not controlling. I have a husband who prefers that I let him know where I am as a courtesy(because he worries), but does not control where I go, so that is how I perceived John’s actions.

    As for why there is so much conflict and not as much loving shown in the strip, that is for drama. If John and Elly were always well behaved and loving toward each other, besides being unrealistic, the strip would be boring.

     •  Reply
Sign in to comment

More From For Better or For Worse