Frazz by Jef Mallett for March 25, 2018

  1. Img 4741
    Ninette  over 6 years ago

    In order to expose those with an aptitude and/or interest in English to English. To allow most of the rest of us to get a glimpse of what goes into the making of a language.

     •  Reply
  2. Missing large
    GreasyOldTam  over 6 years ago

    Do student still diagram sentences?

     •  Reply
  3. Bluedog
    Bilan  over 6 years ago

    You learn sentence structures so that nobody complains about your postings on GoComics.

     •  Reply
  4. Jmao9763
    mddshubby2005  over 6 years ago

    “It’s a lot of exasperating, time-consuming work that, even if you do get it just right, no body will ever see in that form anyway.” One day, I hope Caulfield’s mother will say this about parenting him to his future bride.

     •  Reply
  5. Missing large
    jpayne4040  over 6 years ago

    Because I said so—-End of discussion!

     •  Reply
  6. Ignatz
    Ignatz Premium Member over 6 years ago

    To examine the grammatical construction of the sentence, and learn the parts of speech. Not a good example, Caulfield.

    And if you ever try to learn a foreign language, already knowing the difference between a direct object, an indirect object, and a predicate nominative makes it a LOT easier.

     •  Reply
  7. Grandpa hef
    Jeff0811  over 6 years ago

    What I’m wondering, and pardon my grammar and sentence structure here, it’s been awhile since I’ve subjugated predicates and what not, and I have a problem with run on sentences and such, but what I’m wondering is if an English teacher would request an explanation with the words “what for”? It seems to me saying, “Please explain” would be better coming from an English teacher.

    To me it is as if one is substituting the words “Pardon me, can you please repeat that”, with the word, (I must admit this is a pet peeve of mine) “Huh?”.

     •  Reply
  8. Purple hippo of happiness centered
    archipelago Premium Member over 6 years ago

    Because people will see your sentences. And understanding the elements allows you to create more effective sentences, and (as someone already pointed out) helps when learning a foreign language.

     •  Reply
  9. Gocomic avatar
    sandpiper  over 6 years ago

    Caulfield’s nickname could be circlelocutious as he finally got back to the point he was plotting to make from the beginning

     •  Reply
  10. Copy of msg apa181
    The Brooklyn Accent Premium Member over 6 years ago

    The problem is that (1) to communicate any but the simplest ideas effectively in any language requires an understanding of the structure of that language, and (2) it takes time, practice, and some analytical skill to learn that structure, and (3) developing all that out of nothing involves processes that are often tedious—just as learning addition and multiplication tables, and learning to analyze story problems in order to abstract the mathematical relationships that represent them, are tedious but often necessary steps toward understanding the mathematics that govern our world.

    Some of us have a natural aptitude for language, or math, and it all comes easily and intuitively; others ultimately find these tools are a help, tedious though they may have been to learn.

    Diagramming sentences is tedious, but it replaced an even more tedious method of analyzing the structure of a sentence: parsing it out loud.

    https://opinionator.blogs.nytimes.com/2012/03/26/a-picture-of-language

    People have developed other methods of analyzing sentence structure, and they’re tedious too. When someone finds a way that’s effective as a teaching tool and not tedious, the pedagogical world will rejoice.

     •  Reply
  11. Missing large
    oldwolf1951  over 6 years ago

    There was once a story about why it was good to know how to diagram a sentence structure. The story goes that there was a law that none of the lawyers in court could figure out what the heck it meant. They called in an English teacher and she diagramed the sentence structure. When she got it down to the basics, they found in effect that the law was contradicting itself and threw the whole suit out.

     •  Reply
  12. Taz by abovetheflames
    danketaz Premium Member over 6 years ago

    Any chance of just wadding the sentence up and shoving it in a drawer with the rest of the paragraph?

     •  Reply
  13. Hipshotbellestarr
    scaeva Premium Member over 6 years ago

    Why diagram sentences? To learn the proper use of the English language. And since when do they teach that, anymore? I haven’t spoken to anyone, other than a few successful authors, who were taught this, in years.

     •  Reply
  14. Missing large
    Stephen Gilberg  over 6 years ago

    I learned sentence diagrams for one advisory in seventh grade. Today I can’t diagram complex sentences. But I think it helped me with the concept of parallel structure, which in turn helps me proofread.

     •  Reply
  15. Missing large
    Uncle Bob  over 6 years ago

    Ok Caulie, diagram your last question and I’ll let you off the hook…

     •  Reply
  16. Missing large
    ken in tx  over 6 years ago

    Thought is sub-motal speech. Diagramming sentences helps you clarify your thoughts.

     •  Reply
  17. Snoopy laughs
    HappyDog/ᵀʳʸ ᴮᵒᶻᵒ ⁴ ᵗʰᵉ ᶠᵘⁿ ᵒᶠ ᶦᵗ Premium Member over 6 years ago

    Wow, interesting discussion! So what I’m getting out of all of this is, when you fold fitted sheets correctly, all the corners have to fit inside each other? Thanks.

     •  Reply
  18. Tumblr mbbz3vrusj1qdlmheo1 250
    Night-Gaunt49[Bozo is Boffo]  over 6 years ago

    So does anyone have the data on how it is taught now?

     •  Reply
  19. 100 0515  2018 03 15 17 41 22 utc
    pchemcat  over 6 years ago

    So you can learn how the English language works thus enabling you to write and speak coherently.

     •  Reply
  20. Gsunset tiny
    Seeker149 Premium Member over 6 years ago

    You don’t have to even look under the hood of a car to be a decent driver. But you will also never unlock your vehicle’s full potential without an inherent grasp of its inner workings. The ability to analyze how the words that you use work together to compose thoughts and arguments provides a strong instinctive foundation for critical thinking, which WILL be extremely useful in everyday life. As a Math teacher, I observe a similar dynamic in the lessons I teach. I’m not shy about admitting to my students that they will never use 99% of the formulas and algorithms that I teach them. However, there is no better class for manipulating symbolic concepts, interpreting implicit or explicit information, and consistently applying even more critical thinking.

     •  Reply
Sign in to comment

More From Frazz