In my experience Occam’s Razor is whichever explanation requires the fewest assumptions. A Google search on “Carl Sagan invisible dragon” (without the quotes) does a good job of explaining it.
My dad told me that he had a dog out on the ranch that dug itself down into a gopher hole and then couldn’t get out. He didn’t find the dog for months.
The late great hound Mr. Duke before tearing into grass and dirt always tilted his head back and forth as if to get a better listen from what lay below. He never caught anything just the same.
What you’ve got going here, Jeffrey, is not a theory, it’s a hypothesis, which is a candidate being tested against reality to see if it can eventually earn the status of theory, which is an explanation so well supported by evidence that it’s pretty much universally accepted by scientists as true. Examples include the theory of optics, the germ theory of disease, the atomic theory of matter, the molecular theory of thermodynamics, the theory of relativity, the continental-plate theory of tectonics, the theory of gravitation, the natural-selection theory of evolution, and so on.
With respect to the word “the” in front of “theory”, scientists understand that, in each case, there’s really only a single, widely accepted explanation for all the observable phenomena, so they feel justified in using the definite article. Contrast that with quantum mechanics, which nobody really understands or has a good explanation for. Nobody ever talks about the theory of quantum mechanics (or even a theory); all we have are observations that nobody can make any sense out of.
Occam’s Razor – the simplest explanation that adequately explains an event is most likely true.
Murphey’s blunt instrument – the explanation that involves the longest sequence of improbable events and has the most conspirators is most likely to be believed.
Bilan over 1 year ago
Who came up with the idea for Occam’s Razor? It’s not the obvious, William of Ockham. So that idea lost it’s credibility.
.
The first known usage was by Durandus of Saint-Pourçain.
GreasyOldTam over 1 year ago
Yeah, I don’’t know about that Occam’s razor stuff. In my experience the right answer is usually right. Simple has nothing to do with it.
HidariMak over 1 year ago
In my experience Occam’s Razor is whichever explanation requires the fewest assumptions. A Google search on “Carl Sagan invisible dragon” (without the quotes) does a good job of explaining it.
danketaz Premium Member over 1 year ago
A Hole Is To Dig.
Sanspareil over 1 year ago
Occam’s razor was rather bloodied when he shaved without the best shaving cream!
Doug K over 1 year ago
What is it called when the (so-called) “obvious” is obviously not so obvious or very obvious (at all)?
cmerb over 1 year ago
And just how are they going to get him out of the hole ?
Out of the Past over 1 year ago
Our dachshund loved to dig. Toward the end, I think she lived to dig.
mrwiskers over 1 year ago
I just read that bias (which we inherently possess) is a force.
mistercatworks over 1 year ago
Should have changed the blade on his Occam’s Razor years ago.
ms-ss over 1 year ago
I wasn’t too sure about Occam’s Razor, but I remember Schrödinger’s Paradox. Saw it many times on reruns of BBT.
sandpiper over 1 year ago
It’s a parallel to Sherlock Holmes’ theory. i.e., once you have eliminated the impossible, “whatever remains, however improbable, must be the truth”.
[see Lexicology at https://www.lexology.com/library/detail.aspx?g=a26be156-7f82-429e-9477-ccf9ca2e5487]
morningglory73 Premium Member over 1 year ago
Look at all the big feet!
vaughnrl2003 Premium Member over 1 year ago
My dad told me that he had a dog out on the ranch that dug itself down into a gopher hole and then couldn’t get out. He didn’t find the dog for months.
twagner003 over 1 year ago
If you don’t utilize Occam’s razor, sometimes you have to deal with the Sword of Damocles.
Papakillamon over 1 year ago
The late great hound Mr. Duke before tearing into grass and dirt always tilted his head back and forth as if to get a better listen from what lay below. He never caught anything just the same.
198.23.5.11 over 1 year ago
If he strikes oil, I get half
Richard S Russell Premium Member over 1 year ago
What you’ve got going here, Jeffrey, is not a theory, it’s a hypothesis, which is a candidate being tested against reality to see if it can eventually earn the status of theory, which is an explanation so well supported by evidence that it’s pretty much universally accepted by scientists as true. Examples include the theory of optics, the germ theory of disease, the atomic theory of matter, the molecular theory of thermodynamics, the theory of relativity, the continental-plate theory of tectonics, the theory of gravitation, the natural-selection theory of evolution, and so on.
With respect to the word “the” in front of “theory”, scientists understand that, in each case, there’s really only a single, widely accepted explanation for all the observable phenomena, so they feel justified in using the definite article. Contrast that with quantum mechanics, which nobody really understands or has a good explanation for. Nobody ever talks about the theory of quantum mechanics (or even a theory); all we have are observations that nobody can make any sense out of.
Count Olaf Premium Member over 1 year ago
Maybe he dug it for the same reason that guy climbed Mt Everest, “Because It’s There”. :)
anomaly over 1 year ago
He heard them speaking Chinese.
Redd Panda over 1 year ago
I used Occam’s razor to try and shave Schrödinger’s cat.
It didn’t go as planned.
Oh well, back to the Autocad. (No one uses drawing boards anymore.)
monya_43 over 1 year ago
The obvious thing is that Petey is now down in a hole and can’t get himself out.
willie_mctell over 1 year ago
I think the minimal assumption is that Petey likes to dig holes.
Ka`ōnōhi`ula`okahōkūmiomio`ehiku Premium Member over 1 year ago
Those Jack Russells: If bored for a minute they will find or invent a task.
mindjob over 1 year ago
I never knew the appeal of a sleeping Bigfoot tribe, until now
Godfreydaniel over 1 year ago
Bigfoots sleeping in the hole is at least plausible, but yetis sleeping there would just be silly!
DM2860 over 1 year ago
Since the horse can talk with Petey and Danae, the obvious solution is to ask the horse.
swenbu Premium Member over 1 year ago
These last couple strips have been great because they’ve elicited so many very humorous responses! Thanks to you all, as well as Wiley!!
goboboyd over 1 year ago
He smelled something fetid to roll in.
dflak over 1 year ago
Occam’s Razor – the simplest explanation that adequately explains an event is most likely true.
Murphey’s blunt instrument – the explanation that involves the longest sequence of improbable events and has the most conspirators is most likely to be believed.
T... over 1 year ago
Occam’s razor, when Occam opened the box he saw the cat had slit it’s own throat with the razor…
NWdryad over 1 year ago
Jack Russell terrier is all you need to know.
Nuliajuk over 1 year ago
Last time I used one of Occam’s razors to shave my legs, I kept nicking my ankles and bleeding. Went back to my usual brand.
Redd Panda over 1 year ago
Hey! Maybe he found Morlocks? Could be.
https://timemachine.fandom.com/wiki/Morlocks
pamela welch Premium Member over 1 year ago
My friends have always had Jack Russell’s; pretty sure Danae is right in this instance.
Mostly Water Premium Member over 1 year ago
Occam’s razor is absolute nonsense.
EdmundBabe over 1 year ago
And just by capitalizing the opposite is true.
eddi-TBH over 1 year ago
He does that deliberately to see the look on their faces.
Isenthor1978 over 1 year ago
Danae: “Why did you dig a hole?” Petey: “Because it wasn’t there.”
Say What? Premium Member over 1 year ago
Speaking of being in a deep hole, tRump was indicted on federal charges today.
freshmeet2030 over 1 year ago
Did he turn qupublican?
DaBump Premium Member over 1 year ago
the interpretation and application of Occam’s razor can be quite controversial.