Even if Holiday originated from Holy Day, that’s not its modern meaning. And besides, even if you intend it as Holy Day, that’s still more inclusive because every religion has some concept of Holiness.
The thing that ol’ Al doesn’t get: There are multiple ACTUAL religions. With independent holy days. If you’re being pedantic even non-religious special days are called (in English) “holiday”. Welcome to English.
Stop. No one is telling you that you can’t say Merry Christmas. Happy Holidays is simply meant to show respect for those of us who DON’T celebrate Christmas. After all, Christianity is a minority religion in the US.
So then, why is it the ‘Holier than Thou’s’ that go bat poop crazy when people say Happy Holidays? or Season’s Greetings.
There are many holidays that are not religious. And when the Brits say they are going on holiday, more often than not it has nothing to do with religion.
Some Christians like to think it bothers nonbelievers.
I don’t mind saying merry Christmas or happy Hanukkah, or whatever else to others because I want them to enjoy this time of year. I enjoy Christmas because it has always been a time of meeting families and celebrating life in the middle of winter.
Why are we giving in to a hand full of self centered, narcissistic cowards???If “THEY” don’t like your opinion or beliefs, and traditions, they protest until everyone caves to their selfish WHIMS!
STAND UP AMERICA and defy their outrageous behavior! Don’t cave, and keep believing and doing what YOU know and stop worrying about what “OTHERS “ think”!
This land is our land, our country and let FREEDOM RING!
in my 65 years, in some of the “wokest” places on the planet, I have never heard anything other than “You too” in response to “Merry Christmas”. It’s simply not an issue (except in the minds of conservatives).
My wife is Jewish. She’s not observant, but many of her relatives are. I’m certainly not going to wish them a Merry Christmas. There’s such a thing as being polite. Perhaps it’s even among the Christian virtues?
People who actually know Scripture would be including Advent, the Annunciation, the Solemnity of Mary, Epiphany, Hannukah, Milad an-Nabi (Mawlid), as well as the Nativity.
We have a Jewish friend; her mother and my wife became friends. Every Christmas my wife would send the Mother a “Happy Holidays” card and she would send us one that said “Merry Christmas”. The “War on Christmas” crap is a tired old faked outrage by the right wingers. As usual Goodwyn is a few years behind reality.
Holy Day? Like Yom Kippur? Or Ramadan? Or it could also refer to the Roman holy day of Saturnalia
Because we all know that Christ isn’t born on Christmas The Romans would never had required the Census to be completed in the Winter. People would have starved to death on the road.
The most probable date would have been in August after the harvesting of the first crops. Other records point to September.
I gave up trying to be PC about this. I just go ahead and wish people a Merry Christmas. If they’re insulted by it, then they can either fuss at me or say “Thank you.” For me, it’s kind of like Mother’s Day. I don’t have any children, but when people say “Happy Mother’s Day,” I just smile and thank them, because there’s no need to make an issue of it.
But “haligdaeg” was used mean both “a consecrated day or religious festival” and “a day on which ordinary activities and work are suspended; a day of festivities,” i.e., a largely secular day off. To avoid confusion, “haligdaeg” was used to mean the secular occasions and “halig daeg,” two words, signified the religious “holy days.” This distinction has carried over into modern English, where we have used, since about the 16th century, “holiday” in a broad sense but “holy day” in only a religious sense. – word detective
Typical. “Happy Holidays” isn’t about the exclusion of Christianity. It’s about the INCLUSION of other religious celebrations. So, no. Liberals heads aren’t exploding because we get this notion. But Christian conservatives—a waning bunch—can’t accept that. Their loss!
Every year same old thing. Atheists and secular leftists come out in attack mode on Christmas and religion in general. “Happy Holidays “ is fine but the “holier (heh) than thou” witch ‘splaining’ lecture is unnecessary.
Funny how it’s always the Jews and Christians attacked but never Muslims. Of course, the reason for that is the death fatwa, slitting the throat response for disrespecting Islam.
sevaar777 over 2 years ago
Only AG would believe atheist’s have meltdowns over the origin of words.
LookingGlass Premium Member over 2 years ago
If you really want to drive “them” crazy, just wish them a Happy Festivus and watch their heads explode!!!
/SHMIRK/
mr_sherman Premium Member over 2 years ago
As if anyone but a trumpist wouldn’t know that.
Daeder over 2 years ago
Even if Holiday originated from Holy Day, that’s not its modern meaning. And besides, even if you intend it as Holy Day, that’s still more inclusive because every religion has some concept of Holiness.
Concretionist over 2 years ago
The thing that ol’ Al doesn’t get: There are multiple ACTUAL religions. With independent holy days. If you’re being pedantic even non-religious special days are called (in English) “holiday”. Welcome to English.
baroden Premium Member over 2 years ago
Stop. No one is telling you that you can’t say Merry Christmas. Happy Holidays is simply meant to show respect for those of us who DON’T celebrate Christmas. After all, Christianity is a minority religion in the US.
GiantShetlandPony over 2 years ago
So then, why is it the ‘Holier than Thou’s’ that go bat poop crazy when people say Happy Holidays? or Season’s Greetings.
There are many holidays that are not religious. And when the Brits say they are going on holiday, more often than not it has nothing to do with religion.
Say What Now‽ Premium Member over 2 years ago
Some Christians like to think it bothers nonbelievers.
I don’t mind saying merry Christmas or happy Hanukkah, or whatever else to others because I want them to enjoy this time of year. I enjoy Christmas because it has always been a time of meeting families and celebrating life in the middle of winter.
Zebrastripes over 2 years ago
PC in America is destructive!
Why are we giving in to a hand full of self centered, narcissistic cowards???If “THEY” don’t like your opinion or beliefs, and traditions, they protest until everyone caves to their selfish WHIMS!
STAND UP AMERICA and defy their outrageous behavior! Don’t cave, and keep believing and doing what YOU know and stop worrying about what “OTHERS “ think”!
This land is our land, our country and let FREEDOM RING!
1BlackLivesMatter Premium Member over 2 years ago
Great ’toon! Merry Christmas to all!
The Nodding Head over 2 years ago
I say “Happy Holidays.” I welcome whatever positive greetings people say to me.
suzalee over 2 years ago
Creating a non issue to get angry about. Some people just love feeling angry. They are addicted to it.
NobodyAwesome Premium Member over 2 years ago
This is a classic example of how someone can believe in whatever lie you tell them, if you repeat it enough.
Pickled Pete over 2 years ago
Make it an issue if you are pandering to the religious vote..
Vidrinath Premium Member over 2 years ago
Oh Al….as if I take the whining complaints of the “Alternative facts” seriously.
You are from the cult of “Everything I don’t like is Socialism”
When you draw this it just makes me want to ask you to define every word you have written out and cite you source.
Teto85 Premium Member over 2 years ago
Yup, it includes Diwali, Hannukah, Festivus and Kwanzaa as well as Christmas, Winter Solstice, Saturnalia, and a few others.
Bendarling1 over 2 years ago
Right Republican
ChristopherBurns over 2 years ago
in my 65 years, in some of the “wokest” places on the planet, I have never heard anything other than “You too” in response to “Merry Christmas”. It’s simply not an issue (except in the minds of conservatives).
LJZ Premium Member over 2 years ago
Festive Greetings to All!
lonecat over 2 years ago
My wife is Jewish. She’s not observant, but many of her relatives are. I’m certainly not going to wish them a Merry Christmas. There’s such a thing as being polite. Perhaps it’s even among the Christian virtues?
fusilier over 2 years ago
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2jzhd0SU8k4
People who actually know Scripture would be including Advent, the Annunciation, the Solemnity of Mary, Epiphany, Hannukah, Milad an-Nabi (Mawlid), as well as the Nativity.
fusilier
James 2:24
Frankfreak over 2 years ago
Happy Holidays for me = The season and Merry Christmas and Happy New Year. Who , legitimately, gets upset over happy greetings?
DrDon1 over 2 years ago
Goodwyn makes another contribution to learning…
jack666 Premium Member over 2 years ago
We have a Jewish friend; her mother and my wife became friends. Every Christmas my wife would send the Mother a “Happy Holidays” card and she would send us one that said “Merry Christmas”. The “War on Christmas” crap is a tired old faked outrage by the right wingers. As usual Goodwyn is a few years behind reality.
smartgrr over 2 years ago
Yes, but holy day could refer to the previous pagan holiday that Christmas took over.
goblue86 over 2 years ago
Happy Pagan Ritual!
charliekane over 2 years ago
Ian Anderson’s take:
https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=&cad=rja&uact=8&ved=2ahUKEwif0-fm3eP0AhW2AZ0JHZ5QCX8QyCl6BAgPEAM&url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DXJS9TjjHxx8&usg=AOvVaw1xNiPziT9nUhzRkZUgpJUy
jhayesd31 over 2 years ago
Holy Day? Like Yom Kippur? Or Ramadan? Or it could also refer to the Roman holy day of Saturnalia
Because we all know that Christ isn’t born on Christmas The Romans would never had required the Census to be completed in the Winter. People would have starved to death on the road.
The most probable date would have been in August after the harvesting of the first crops. Other records point to September.
Can someone draw Goodwyn’s head exploding’
Radish the wordsmith over 2 years ago
War head on Christmas, right wingers are so weird.
Lola85 Premium Member over 2 years ago
I gave up trying to be PC about this. I just go ahead and wish people a Merry Christmas. If they’re insulted by it, then they can either fuss at me or say “Thank you.” For me, it’s kind of like Mother’s Day. I don’t have any children, but when people say “Happy Mother’s Day,” I just smile and thank them, because there’s no need to make an issue of it.
Johnny on the Spot over 2 years ago
Another BS cartoon about a non-issue. The so called “War on Christmas” was a made up issue by the Republicans to rile up their base.
braindead Premium Member over 2 years ago
Goodwyn again shows off those Trump Disciple analysis skills.
Patjade over 2 years ago
Wow, Al points out the obvious. He must have blown his own mind.
lawguy05 over 2 years ago
Great strip, AI. Let’s keep the CHRIST in Christmas. Let’s Go Brandon!
ferddo over 2 years ago
Gotta try to keep a “war on Christmas” going, even though there never was one…
librarylady59 over 2 years ago
But “haligdaeg” was used mean both “a consecrated day or religious festival” and “a day on which ordinary activities and work are suspended; a day of festivities,” i.e., a largely secular day off. To avoid confusion, “haligdaeg” was used to mean the secular occasions and “halig daeg,” two words, signified the religious “holy days.” This distinction has carried over into modern English, where we have used, since about the 16th century, “holiday” in a broad sense but “holy day” in only a religious sense. – word detective
librarylady59 over 2 years ago
There a “he” goes again, mansplaining.
Rich Douglas over 2 years ago
Typical. “Happy Holidays” isn’t about the exclusion of Christianity. It’s about the INCLUSION of other religious celebrations. So, no. Liberals heads aren’t exploding because we get this notion. But Christian conservatives—a waning bunch—can’t accept that. Their loss!
Baslim the Beggar Premium Member over 2 years ago
Solstice Salutations!
Kracklin Rosie - “Tolo Dan Nan Galad” Premium Member over 2 years ago
Every year same old thing. Atheists and secular leftists come out in attack mode on Christmas and religion in general. “Happy Holidays “ is fine but the “holier (heh) than thou” witch ‘splaining’ lecture is unnecessary.
Funny how it’s always the Jews and Christians attacked but never Muslims. Of course, the reason for that is the death fatwa, slitting the throat response for disrespecting Islam.
IDEALeducation over 2 years ago
In my house, we call it ‘winter vacation’.
Frankfreak over 2 years ago
Would help is evangelicals and other “christians” kept the teachings of Yeshua in Christianity.
apfelzra Premium Member over 2 years ago
This is not a thing, Goodwyn.
calliarcale over 2 years ago
I prefer “Happy Holidays” because it isn’t Christmastide yet AND because it doesn’t needlessly offend some people.
It’s a season for goodwill towards our fellow people. What’s so hard about that?
MuddyUSA Premium Member over 2 years ago
Jen Psaki?
Ontman over 2 years ago
Payne worthy.