If I only get one slice, it will be hard to pick between the pecan and the pumpkin. But I’ll be someone’s guest tomorrow, and I’m sure whatever they have will be fine.
I don’t like the traditional pies like pumpkin, mincemeat or pecan. The only ones I like on the chart are coconut cream and apple. For our Thanksgiving dinner I am planning to have a Public Mango Key Lime pie. If I can’t get that I will get the regular Key Lime one.
Mincemeat was my mother’s favorite, rhubarb was my dad’s favorite and I don’t like either of them. My mom’s other favorite was elderberry pie whereas my dad’s number two would have been apple pie. Me, I go for the coconut creme or lemon meringue. I do make a mean pumpkin pie though.
FreihEitner Premium Member 11 months ago
Sadly no chocolate meringue.
Sue Ellen 11 months ago
My uncle made a great cranberry-cherry pie!
angelolady Premium Member 11 months ago
I love the rhubarb pie. All for me.
blunebottle 11 months ago
Throw away the pumpkin, apple and coconut creme and make more room for the good ones.
Charliegirl Premium Member 11 months ago
Drooling here………………………
TStyle78 11 months ago
Make that!
Doug K 11 months ago
The area of a round pie pie chart is pi r squared
derdave969 11 months ago
My aunt used to make an egg custard pie with sour cherries in it. Whenever she’d ask what kind of pie I’d like that was my answer.
RonBerg13 Premium Member 11 months ago
The Pie chart of all Pie charts.
ThreeDogDad Premium Member 11 months ago
That pie and a cup of coffee would be my perfect Thanksgiving feast.
Kaputnik 11 months ago
If I only get one slice, it will be hard to pick between the pecan and the pumpkin. But I’ll be someone’s guest tomorrow, and I’m sure whatever they have will be fine.
SusieB 11 months ago
I don’t like the traditional pies like pumpkin, mincemeat or pecan. The only ones I like on the chart are coconut cream and apple. For our Thanksgiving dinner I am planning to have a Public Mango Key Lime pie. If I can’t get that I will get the regular Key Lime one.
NCGalFromNJ 11 months ago
I prefer banana cream pie, a whole one.
Lee26 Premium Member 11 months ago
Pie buffet!!
Tired 11 months ago
You take the circumference and divide it by the diameter. That’s how you get pi.
PoodleGroomer 11 months ago
We need key lime and cherry.
Pluggergirl 11 months ago
Sweet Potato is my fav. Thank you Patti Labelle.
totalspaceman2010 11 months ago
In my family, it was pumpkin, apple, or jello cheesecake.
rickmac1937 Premium Member 11 months ago
What no Cherry pie?
betseytacy 11 months ago
what about LEMON MERINGUE? or BANANA MERINGUE??!!!
A# 466 11 months ago
Gooseberry for me. Second on the rhubarb. Both a bit tart — not gooey sweet like the store-bought “gobbage.” Wouldn’t feed that stuff to a billy goat.
Steverino Premium Member 11 months ago
But you have to eat it on March 14.
scote1379 Premium Member 11 months ago
Love Mincemeat pie have to make my own , I flavor it with Single Malt Whiskey , Yum!
anomalous4 11 months ago
Replace half the coconut with French Silk, & all the mincemeat with cherry, & it’s a deal!
lsnrchrd.1 Premium Member 11 months ago
I’d buy a pie that’s 1/4 each strawberry rhubarb, key lime, blueberry and pecan.
Also a cheesecake with at least 4 different flavors/types.
Better include a gallon of Baskin-Robbin’s peppermint ice cream — is it available yet for 2023?
thejanith Premium Member 11 months ago
No chocolate cream? Oh, wait. That one gets a whole pie chart all to itself, right?
Mike Baldwin creator 11 months ago
Yummy and funny!
mistercatworks 11 months ago
This would make a great family-pleasing pie but how would you segregate the meringue? :)
jbarnes 11 months ago
It looks like each of us has a different pie chart.
Katzi428 11 months ago
No mincemeat for me, thanks!
jtburgess Premium Member 11 months ago
At my house, the coconut is replaced by chocolate peanut butter.
crazeekatlady 11 months ago
Pumpkin, chocolate silk, cherry or pineapple for me.
pchemcat 11 months ago
Mincemeat was my mother’s favorite, rhubarb was my dad’s favorite and I don’t like either of them. My mom’s other favorite was elderberry pie whereas my dad’s number two would have been apple pie. Me, I go for the coconut creme or lemon meringue. I do make a mean pumpkin pie though.
7afrz6 Premium Member 11 months ago
Forgot Cherry Pie, and gave to much space for Mincemeat, rhubarb and coconut. 3 of the worse pie ever made.
Lady Bri 11 months ago
What, no chess pie??? Sacrilege!
amanda.elliott3619 11 months ago
everything but mincemeat blueberry and pumpkin :)
thomascd1 11 months ago
What…no sweet potato?
oakie817 11 months ago
HIPPY THANKSGIVING!!!
aussie399 Premium Member 8 months ago
Pumpkin is about 100% too big