It is impossible to tell if it works or not. You might never change the mind of the person you are debating, but you might change the minds of 3rd parties that are reading the debate. If the 3rd parties don’t comment, you don’t know if your comment changed anyone’s mind.
The problem isn’t social media. The problem is always the ignorant, brain-washed people who are afraid of everything but think they know better than everyone else.
Perhaps this is true, but it doesn’t mean we should do it anyway. Primal scream therapy is quieter on social media and it’s easy to find a shouting buddy or two (and also less violent than the alternative).
Gossip, misinformation, prattle, propaganda and so on have always been there. Social media merely speeds the dissemination of falsehoods. It also has a damaging effect on the filters we rely upon, also known as expertise. In the past five years, I have seen a marked decrease in the respect for expertise. That, frankly, is one of the greatest dangers of social media. When everyone can scream what they think (with or without evidence or justification) then it’s tempting to ignore those who actually know what they’re talking about.
people belive anything. good example is keystone xl. everyone thinks it`s a whole pipe system when in reality it was just supposed to be a shortcut from the oil fields in canada to kansas . in reality keystone has been up and running for the better part of six years.
I have an acquaintance that likes to hold forth at some length on any number of topics. He usually concludes with a triumphant glare exclaiming, “Am I Right?” I replied, “Are you asking or stating?” He got really, really mad.
And has anybody on social media ever changed their minds about a politician or party no matter HOW impassioned the plea is? I doubt it. It’s like trying to convince a Cubs fan to root for the White Sox. So why try?
I remember when loonies just walked the streets talking to themselves and people stepped away from them. Now they can join forces in the web-o-sphere and create Movements (which are often on a par with the other kind of “movements” they create).
Of course it works! Now, where’s my free PBS swag in exchange for the Exposure when I mention it online somewhere? Now, let me check the markets…I see that all of the Exposure I have received over the years has increased in value from Jack Squat to Diddly Squat.
replied to a comment on this comic page today. They were beating a dead horse (IMHO) and I questioned how they were making the world complaining about it here.
Preach, brother! Amen! You’re preaching to the choir, here, i was just “saying” that to myself while analyzing the last ep of parks and rec and following a daydream-type deal where i looked at everything i liked with the “characters” in them while in my “hospital room,” imagining how the actors and writers involved proved that point with satire and fun, leading to how all America wants the world to act, etc. Sort of insane coincidence, huh? dan aka ryan
BE THIS GUY over 2 years ago
Or you can post Sponge Bob gifs.
Kveldulf over 2 years ago
Social media is a total ghughugh.
BasilBruce over 2 years ago
He mistakenly thought someone had said to him, “If that’s your opinion, go to well.”
Concretionist over 2 years ago
It’s an echo chamber.
sirbadger over 2 years ago
It is impossible to tell if it works or not. You might never change the mind of the person you are debating, but you might change the minds of 3rd parties that are reading the debate. If the 3rd parties don’t comment, you don’t know if your comment changed anyone’s mind.
Cornelius Noodleman over 2 years ago
I threw a penny in a well.
Imagine over 2 years ago
The problem isn’t social media. The problem is always the ignorant, brain-washed people who are afraid of everything but think they know better than everyone else.
socalvillaguy Premium Member over 2 years ago
Perhaps this is true, but it doesn’t mean we should do it anyway. Primal scream therapy is quieter on social media and it’s easy to find a shouting buddy or two (and also less violent than the alternative).
iggyman over 2 years ago
I have had people shout me down so I could not get my point across, stinks!
Gent over 2 years ago
But now, with Elon Musk on the board, social media is going to get better.
Sanspareil over 2 years ago
Kevin Ayers described it beautifully in his song!
“Shouting in a bucket Blues”
MayCauseBurns over 2 years ago
Shouting is not enough, you have to screech and reeeeeeeee
some idiot from R'lyeh Premium Member over 2 years ago
Oh good, it’s the social media strip again.
Kayak_Brian over 2 years ago
Arguing with morons on twitter is like correcting Graffiti on a public toilet wall that you will never need to use again. — Ricky Gervais
zerotvus over 2 years ago
but, the message is clear………
NeedaChuckle Premium Member over 2 years ago
It is a lot of fun sometimes to see people rationalize insanity.
papajim545 over 2 years ago
Trumplicans
cdward over 2 years ago
Gossip, misinformation, prattle, propaganda and so on have always been there. Social media merely speeds the dissemination of falsehoods. It also has a damaging effect on the filters we rely upon, also known as expertise. In the past five years, I have seen a marked decrease in the respect for expertise. That, frankly, is one of the greatest dangers of social media. When everyone can scream what they think (with or without evidence or justification) then it’s tempting to ignore those who actually know what they’re talking about.
Ellis97 over 2 years ago
Social media is the cause of your sorrow.
tripwire45 over 2 years ago
I wonder if Elon Musk joining the board of directors of twitter will change anything?
HOTLOTUS1 over 2 years ago
um. no. it’s social media
F-Flash over 2 years ago
Where words are many, transgression is unavoidable, but he or she who restrains their tongue is wise.
[Unnamed Reader - 5461d7] over 2 years ago
people belive anything. good example is keystone xl. everyone thinks it`s a whole pipe system when in reality it was just supposed to be a shortcut from the oil fields in canada to kansas . in reality keystone has been up and running for the better part of six years.
IshkaBibel1 over 2 years ago
It is impossible to change someone’s opinion when you start by telling them they are wrong.
Mentor397 over 2 years ago
The problem is that people have to bring it up, all the time, even when we’re not discussing politics.
Bookworm over 2 years ago
I have an acquaintance that likes to hold forth at some length on any number of topics. He usually concludes with a triumphant glare exclaiming, “Am I Right?” I replied, “Are you asking or stating?” He got really, really mad.
Lee26 Premium Member over 2 years ago
And has anybody on social media ever changed their minds about a politician or party no matter HOW impassioned the plea is? I doubt it. It’s like trying to convince a Cubs fan to root for the White Sox. So why try?
aerotica69 over 2 years ago
I remember when loonies just walked the streets talking to themselves and people stepped away from them. Now they can join forces in the web-o-sphere and create Movements (which are often on a par with the other kind of “movements” they create).
uniquename over 2 years ago
It’s more like two people with cans on a string yelling at the same time.
SteveHL over 2 years ago
I know that this isn’t the point of this strip, but Rat’s drawing skills are quite good now.
GlenGoodwin over 2 years ago
In scouts we learned to be prepared and virtue is it’s own reward, which the cross for sure get
GlenGoodwin over 2 years ago
Crocks,not cross
MS72 over 2 years ago
He needs a “let things be” tree.
Goat from PBS over 2 years ago
Too high of expectations. The goal should be to voice your opinion.
mombass over 2 years ago
And the intelligent know-it-alls who should know better than to waste their time trying to influence people who “know better than everyone else.”
del_grande Premium Member over 2 years ago
Of course it works! Now, where’s my free PBS swag in exchange for the Exposure when I mention it online somewhere? Now, let me check the markets…I see that all of the Exposure I have received over the years has increased in value from Jack Squat to Diddly Squat.
car2ner over 2 years ago
replied to a comment on this comic page today. They were beating a dead horse (IMHO) and I questioned how they were making the world complaining about it here.
Plods with ...™ over 2 years ago
Stupid is as stupid does.
198.23.5.11 over 2 years ago
Sadly,sometimes it DOES work.And usually for those who deserve to be listened to the least.
198.23.5.11 over 2 years ago
Anybody noticed that Hannity rhymes with insanity?
hmofo813 Premium Member over 2 years ago
Why am I reminded of editorial cartooning?
DO_WHAT_DA_DOG_SEZ (NOT THE REAL ONE) over 2 years ago
“Oddly?”
John W. Vinson Premium Member over 2 years ago
“I went to Jerusalem and spent an afternoon praying at the Wailing Wall”. “What was it like?” “Like talking to a wall!”
Bilan over 2 years ago
Let’s not forget Trump sending Navy deployment instructions on Twitter.
Spiffy over 2 years ago
At least Timmy will get the message.
Baucuva over 2 years ago
Hey! We have those people on GoComics all the time!!
Sisyphos over 2 years ago
“Bob shouting into a well” poses the question, is Rat a better cartoonist than Cartoon-Boy? Answer in a brief essay….
DanielRyanMulligan1 over 2 years ago
Preach, brother! Amen! You’re preaching to the choir, here, i was just “saying” that to myself while analyzing the last ep of parks and rec and following a daydream-type deal where i looked at everything i liked with the “characters” in them while in my “hospital room,” imagining how the actors and writers involved proved that point with satire and fun, leading to how all America wants the world to act, etc. Sort of insane coincidence, huh? dan aka ryan
fulcherdavidl over 2 years ago
When I was younger and worked in a kitchen and things got too much I’d go in the walk-in freezer and scream. Primal scream therapy for cooks.
Bwingblue1 over 2 years ago
LOL! I absolutely LOVE rat’s definition!
aussie399 Premium Member over 2 years ago
And the same level of intelligence, “brain deadness” and utter stupidity that’s needed to be on (anti)social media
The one and only Eldest Arc (now at peace) about 2 years ago
Show this cartoon to someone, if they say pig has the right idea and are serious, oh boy, we got a dumb one