This is comic has caused my morning coffee to spew all over my computer screen! Ha ha ha haaaa! My knees, that crack, pop and snap, totally agree with Lupin, and also Puck’s chart!
A problem I have is that I was made long ago, on Imperial measure and with BSF threads. But now all the new replacement parts are metric, and so none of them fit.
We need a chart that compares (obviously superior) cat knees to (totally inferior) People knees. Perhaps Beatrix can do the research and Sophie can whip out the illustration.
Lupin is going to be That Cat. You know the one, who goes ahead and meows what everycat is thinking regardless of whether it’s tactful or not. Then sits back and sips his (decatfeinated) coffee while every other (Siamese) cat gets his fur ruffled by it.
Strengthening exercises and kaiut yoga repaired my knee enough that I can backpack again at 52. Post-surgery for a torn meniscus. Don’t settle for pain and inactivity; try, try, try to find a solution that works for you. It took me about three years to get through the whole process and it’s been absolutely worth it.
Well, it’s either the knee or the hip…and it often boils down to how said joint has been used/treated throughout life and little bit of genetics (some people are more prone to it than others). I’ve heard overall body weight can sometimes have a role in it too.
Mine lasted 55 years, then I traded them in for titanium and plastic. Walking is great, but I can’t kneel in church, or anywhere else. And if I take a bad fall, its an automatic trip to ER for X-rays to see if I cracked anything. I try not to fall. ;)
Cat knees aren’t perfect, either. I’ve had two cats that had to have ACL surgery (for torn knee ligaments). I told everybody my cat had a football injury.
Despite multiple decades of hiking, biking, extensive walking, standing, and hauling heavy objects. Mine have held up pretty well despite the abuse I’ve heaped on them. My feet and ankles are another matter.
I fully expect to have the ice bags out later, as I will be down on the knees replacing the toilet seat later today. It doesn’t take long, but it will be long enough for the Iill effects to set in.
After spending a few months in Switzerland I’m fairly sure their knees do not have an expiration date. The REAL problem with knees is that there is no warranty.
Now 85 & knees hips are just fine. However need 2 AFOs [ankle foot braces]. Left leg paralyzed from knee down due to Shingles at age 71 because Doctor gave me Shingles shot 72 hours after blisters arrived thinking it would ‘help me’. Then l years later both legs got highest level severe progressive polyneuropathy after back surgery in 2013 to ‘cure’ painful sciatica. Still manage to walk 2 miles a day. However my wife, now 84 had left knee replacement, & right hip replaced. There is always something…. Celebrated between NW Tucson Monsoon storms with my version of Pete Seeger’s Coal Creek March:
The problem with human knees is that people don’t walk properly. Everyone knows how to walk, right? NO. ABSOLUTELY WRONG. Why is this?
Partially because everyone takes it for granted—until injury or merely many years of abuse make it painful and difficult. Having been forced by medical circumstance to relearn the skill twice, I offer the following, taken from a paper I wrote on this many years ago:
Wear proper shoes. These are surprisingly rare. Most people wander around in what I call “foot pillows” that absorb so much of the force of impact while walking that the leg muscles forget how to do their jobs properly. I habitually wear shoes with the thinnest soles I can find. In cold weather, I may be forced to wear thicker soles as protection from the cold, but I still choose footwear with the least cushioning. Also, the shape of the insole should fit your foot, not the other way around.
Walk with a proper gait. If your heel is slamming into the ground or floor with every step, it’s hurting everything up to your cervical spine. As the foot comes down, the knee should be slightly flexed, and the muscles of the leg cushion the impact. Try to develop the habit of having almost the entire foot coming down at once and rolling to the ball of the foot and toes, allowing that leg to take part of the force of the next step.
Shorten your stride. This reduces heel impact and helps you roll into the next step. If you need to go faster, keep the stride the same distance, but make them faster. A good “rule of toe” appear to be for the stride length to be about the width of your shoulders or hips.
I had a bad knee for many years but my doctor fought against doing a replacement because he said I was way too young. 10 years later he gave up and did the replacement.
This is so timely. I will turn 40 in January, and my otherwise perfect knees began hurting three months ago. I have now started PT (like four days ago) and am still 5 months away from 40…..what will be next?? I share Puck’s pessimism.
So weird! My husband had knee replacement surgery just this morning. The doctor just called and said everything went really well. I will go back to the hospital and see him in another hour. (He’s a little past the expiration date) I love the description of two floppy door hinges!
As the owner of two severely-arthritic knees (no cartilage left in either one of ’em! Just bones grinding together!) I agree with Puck and Lupin. Poor design choice!b
I love the cat explanation of our weird knees. Luckily I must not have walked as much as others since my knees haven’t expired yet. Yay for preferring reading and crafting etc. to exercise and stuff. :)
35 years? Where do I go to get my money back! Would have loved to see 35 years on the left knee, instead it was more like 16 to 18. And Puck’s chart is missing ligaments!
One of my cats had a kneecap that would pop out from time to time. Instead of surgery (which doesn’t always work) he learned to just give it a quick shake and pop it back into place. This isn’t so unusual in cats and especially dogs.
jemelvin about 3 years ago
I feel her pain…with two knee replacements. Huh.
deadheadzan about 3 years ago
I think Puck is being a little pessimistic about knees ( as is Burt).
Le'letha Premium Member about 3 years ago
The knee (and the ankle) is the price we pay for opposable thumbs and bipedalism, and I still think we came out on top of that one.
Lady Bri about 3 years ago
LOL at “curse unlocked at 127,750.00 steps”! I have missed Puck’s wonderful charts! ❤
Brian Premium Member about 3 years ago
I was having trouble with my right knee, but I got one of those velcro wrap braces and that’s made a world of difference.
MrsXandamere about 3 years ago
As a 35-year-old whose knee has started bending backwards all the time for no reason, I feel very seen today.
Carlos the clown about 3 years ago
Olive O'Sudden about 3 years ago
This is the most perfect description I and my 47-year-old osteoarthritic knees have ever come across.♥
Sionyx about 3 years ago
…You mean I could have filed a warranty claim when my knee went bad at 14?
WelshRat Premium Member about 3 years ago
Um, Pucky, where did you get that hinge from? The people may need to know which door they’ll struggle to open…
Jungle Empress about 3 years ago
I love Puck’s charts. They make a great comic even better!
ikini Premium Member about 3 years ago
Pain beret. LOL! Yup, that’s where my knees hurt when I overstress them.
Kim Metzger Premium Member about 3 years ago
I still drink milk and take calcium supplements and my knees and legs work fine!
I AM CARTOON LADY! about 3 years ago
This is comic has caused my morning coffee to spew all over my computer screen! Ha ha ha haaaa! My knees, that crack, pop and snap, totally agree with Lupin, and also Puck’s chart!
Robin Harwood about 3 years ago
A problem I have is that I was made long ago, on Imperial measure and with BSF threads. But now all the new replacement parts are metric, and so none of them fit.
Sue Ellen about 3 years ago
Woman, I hope you realize you are not alone! And Georgia, I hope this doesn’t reflect your real life.
some idiot from R'lyeh Premium Member about 3 years ago
Is that 127750 steps, or 12775000 with the separator in a weird place? Both options seems a few orders of magnitude low.
FreyjaRN Premium Member about 3 years ago
Terrific comic!
Biskits about 3 years ago
Knee replacements are a real blessing.
cat19632001 about 3 years ago
We need a chart that compares (obviously superior) cat knees to (totally inferior) People knees. Perhaps Beatrix can do the research and Sophie can whip out the illustration.
cat19632001 about 3 years ago
The Woman clearly didn’t opt for the extended warranty.
cat19632001 about 3 years ago
Lupin is going to be That Cat. You know the one, who goes ahead and meows what everycat is thinking regardless of whether it’s tactful or not. Then sits back and sips his (decatfeinated) coffee while every other (Siamese) cat gets his fur ruffled by it.
Drag0nr1der about 3 years ago
OMGoddess! Laughed till I leaked! So true
rs0204 Premium Member about 3 years ago
35 years??? That’s it. I’m not getting out of bed!
Tigrisan Premium Member about 3 years ago
I dunno, mine went bad at 22 when my husband tried to kill me, but that’s a story for another time…
rs0204 Premium Member about 3 years ago
Actually, my right knee is already an agglomeration of screws and a cadaver parts because of my trip to the bottom of a set of stairs the hard way.
annqueue about 3 years ago
Strengthening exercises and kaiut yoga repaired my knee enough that I can backpack again at 52. Post-surgery for a torn meniscus. Don’t settle for pain and inactivity; try, try, try to find a solution that works for you. It took me about three years to get through the whole process and it’s been absolutely worth it.
ekw555 about 3 years ago
I like the “pain beret”.
and don’t even get me started on the shin design. (not shown)
Happy, happy, happy!!! Premium Member about 3 years ago
It’s all true!
FrannieL Premium Member about 3 years ago
Indeed, I have to see an orthopedic surgeon on October 4th for possible knee replacement. A visit I don’t look forward to, but can’t avoid.
prrdh about 3 years ago
35 years…which is when, by pure coincidence, the warranty expires.
The Good Doctor about 3 years ago
OT: GSD Mom and Akiro update
Code the Enforcer about 3 years ago
For ‘creaky hinges’ as knees tend to be – WD-40 just WON"T fix that … (unfortunately)! … :)
gcottay about 3 years ago
Best wishes for a full if slow recovery. Attempts to overachieve in PT can come a cropper.
scyphi26 about 3 years ago
Well, it’s either the knee or the hip…and it often boils down to how said joint has been used/treated throughout life and little bit of genetics (some people are more prone to it than others). I’ve heard overall body weight can sometimes have a role in it too.
The Wolf In Your Midst about 3 years ago
I’d just like to point out that “Pain Beret” would be a great name for a punk band.
Dreamcat about 3 years ago
Mine lasted 55 years, then I traded them in for titanium and plastic. Walking is great, but I can’t kneel in church, or anywhere else. And if I take a bad fall, its an automatic trip to ER for X-rays to see if I cracked anything. I try not to fall. ;)
cat19632001 about 3 years ago
OMC – kitties have little berets over their knees, too!
GaryCooper about 3 years ago
Cat knees aren’t perfect, either. I’ve had two cats that had to have ACL surgery (for torn knee ligaments). I told everybody my cat had a football injury.
serenasakitty about 3 years ago
Maybe the CURSE UNlOCKED on Puck’s chart is the price needed to fix everything.
Space_cat about 3 years ago
Despite multiple decades of hiking, biking, extensive walking, standing, and hauling heavy objects. Mine have held up pretty well despite the abuse I’ve heaped on them. My feet and ankles are another matter.
Catmom about 3 years ago
I fully expect to have the ice bags out later, as I will be down on the knees replacing the toilet seat later today. It doesn’t take long, but it will be long enough for the Iill effects to set in.
Lara Smith about 3 years ago
My right knee went at 33. Left was 35. Not a DAY more for sure.
La Gata Loca about 3 years ago
After spending a few months in Switzerland I’m fairly sure their knees do not have an expiration date. The REAL problem with knees is that there is no warranty.
willie_mctell about 3 years ago
The human body is a kludge.
Nuliajuk about 3 years ago
Mine didn’t start giving me trouble until getting into a car accident at age 40.
Banjo Gordy Premium Member about 3 years ago
Now 85 & knees hips are just fine. However need 2 AFOs [ankle foot braces]. Left leg paralyzed from knee down due to Shingles at age 71 because Doctor gave me Shingles shot 72 hours after blisters arrived thinking it would ‘help me’. Then l years later both legs got highest level severe progressive polyneuropathy after back surgery in 2013 to ‘cure’ painful sciatica. Still manage to walk 2 miles a day. However my wife, now 84 had left knee replacement, & right hip replaced. There is always something…. Celebrated between NW Tucson Monsoon storms with my version of Pete Seeger’s Coal Creek March:
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1S2uYa7yyCAVnFcOEkCdhIxiAQZ2DLWcy/view?usp=sharing
Jayfbird1969 Premium Member about 3 years ago
Having had an injury to my left knee that chipped my patella I can concur that “pain beret” is an apt name for it.
Teto85 Premium Member about 3 years ago
Could be worse. Cats, dogs, other quadrupeds and birds walk on their toes. Imagine having to walk on your toes.
scaeva Premium Member about 3 years ago
The problem with human knees is that people don’t walk properly. Everyone knows how to walk, right? NO. ABSOLUTELY WRONG. Why is this?
Partially because everyone takes it for granted—until injury or merely many years of abuse make it painful and difficult. Having been forced by medical circumstance to relearn the skill twice, I offer the following, taken from a paper I wrote on this many years ago:
Wear proper shoes. These are surprisingly rare. Most people wander around in what I call “foot pillows” that absorb so much of the force of impact while walking that the leg muscles forget how to do their jobs properly. I habitually wear shoes with the thinnest soles I can find. In cold weather, I may be forced to wear thicker soles as protection from the cold, but I still choose footwear with the least cushioning. Also, the shape of the insole should fit your foot, not the other way around.
Walk with a proper gait. If your heel is slamming into the ground or floor with every step, it’s hurting everything up to your cervical spine. As the foot comes down, the knee should be slightly flexed, and the muscles of the leg cushion the impact. Try to develop the habit of having almost the entire foot coming down at once and rolling to the ball of the foot and toes, allowing that leg to take part of the force of the next step.
Shorten your stride. This reduces heel impact and helps you roll into the next step. If you need to go faster, keep the stride the same distance, but make them faster. A good “rule of toe” appear to be for the stride length to be about the width of your shoulders or hips.
Mr. Reader about 3 years ago
A sense of foreboding hath settled over me.
NWdryad about 3 years ago
I had a bad knee for many years but my doctor fought against doing a replacement because he said I was way too young. 10 years later he gave up and did the replacement.
in-dubio-pro-rainbow about 3 years ago
A mishap injured dem dry bones,
A mishap injured dem dry bones,
A mishap in the armchair of wry ones,
Now hear the word of the Ouch.Knee bone connected to the tile floor
Tile floor disconnected pain beret with a wild roar
(Chorus) Dem bones, dem bones gonna run off soon.
Dem bones, dem bones gonna run off soon.artheaded1 about 3 years ago
“Curse Unlocked” explains it all!
aidankohana about 3 years ago
This is so timely. I will turn 40 in January, and my otherwise perfect knees began hurting three months ago. I have now started PT (like four days ago) and am still 5 months away from 40…..what will be next?? I share Puck’s pessimism.
ltrauth about 3 years ago
Ha ha – yes! Except mine sound more like popcorn or Rice Crispies than a door hinge!
JLChi about 3 years ago
My knees lasted 70 years with no problems. Of course, I am soon to turn 71, so I look back on last year as “the good old days.”
Perkycat about 3 years ago
So weird! My husband had knee replacement surgery just this morning. The doctor just called and said everything went really well. I will go back to the hospital and see him in another hour. (He’s a little past the expiration date) I love the description of two floppy door hinges!
cat19632001 about 3 years ago
Lupin “business casual” loaf.
anne o about 3 years ago
O.T.
Mary Ellen about 3 years ago
As the owner of two severely-arthritic knees (no cartilage left in either one of ’em! Just bones grinding together!) I agree with Puck and Lupin. Poor design choice!b
Mx Crazy Cat Person about 3 years ago
I love the cat explanation of our weird knees. Luckily I must not have walked as much as others since my knees haven’t expired yet. Yay for preferring reading and crafting etc. to exercise and stuff. :)
Miss Mina about 3 years ago
Albert is home!
asrialfeeple about 3 years ago
Better research is badly kneeded.
knight1192a about 3 years ago
35 years? Where do I go to get my money back! Would have loved to see 35 years on the left knee, instead it was more like 16 to 18. And Puck’s chart is missing ligaments!
Tonksquawk about 3 years ago
“Pain Beret”… I love it! Especially since I had a knee replaced last year. :)
rs0204 Premium Member about 3 years ago
Georgia has announced the next Breaking Cat New book will be out in Feb 2022.
The title is: Behind The Scenes With Burt
It looks great and you can pre-order it. More pre-orders will help the book.
Catmom about 3 years ago
My knees do some popping from time to time, but it’s the neck that gives the “rice krispies” effect.
Mary McNeil Premium Member about 3 years ago
One of my cats had a kneecap that would pop out from time to time. Instead of surgery (which doesn’t always work) he learned to just give it a quick shake and pop it back into place. This isn’t so unusual in cats and especially dogs.
Felicity-the-cat about 3 years ago
Knee problems are NOT FUN!!! I’ve had problems with my knees since I was 12 —-or 1972. My sincere condolences to anyone else with similar problems.
Michael G. about 3 years ago
We have your word for it, eh?
KROverton about 3 years ago
My right one went out at 18. It just gave out getting up from a table. It only got worse from there.
about 3 years ago
I’ll be sure to take fewer steps.
stefaninafla about 3 years ago
So far my knees are still going, it’s my intestines that expired! They really do not warn you the warranty expires at 40!
Zook5931 Premium Member 8 days ago
According to puck Messi has useless knees