It’s been done, at least twice that I know of: Science Fiction. One almost exactly like this but without the “tribal elder” bit; the other “something disgusting” but as a tribal story of creation.
Of course Danae wasn’t doing “science” she was doing “sociology”. Or just “story collection”.
This is hilarious. As soon as she says “so I went to the oldest person I know” I was laughing. An unusual, but not unwelcome, strip that combines Danae and Eddy.
Danae, you did the research, a little flawed, but your methodology wasn’t so your grade should be a passing one and for a child your age, very creative.
You can do this experiment at home, kids. Fill your bathtub with warm water, add some sewage and wait. You’ll be amazed at what grows in that soup. guiliani worms, pence sludge, conway suckers and the apex creature, the trump slug. Please wash you hands when done.
That’s like a Stanilaw Lem short story about two space travelers, Gord and Lod, contaminating a planet with their spit, only to later give rise to humanity. I think it’s the Intergalactic Congress and it is in the collection the cyberiad. The origin story is brought to light as Earth tries to gain membership
GASP!!!, Its her! Look at the fish on the left side, its my third grade teacher miss Julian!! I’d know that face anywhere! I knew there was something fishy about her eyes!.
All things came into existence, where and when we do not know.All things will cease to exist, when we do not know. As I age I realize, I will some day cease to exist,when I do not know, nor do I care to!Life is a journey to be lived and I intend to live it as long as I can!
The “Christians”-the ones always protesting the teaching of Evolution-think that a “god”-and actual person/race of “people” are the ones who created life on earth. So Danae, at least according to the hyper xristians who believe that the world is only 5000 years old and Dinosaur bones were planted by this same"group" is correct
Bruno Bozzetto’s 1976 Italian animated film Allegro Non Troppo (musical direction for “fast but not too fast”) is a takeoff on Disney’s Fantasia in that it’s an anthology of fantastical short stories (many of them humorous) that also makes extensive use of classical music as background. The relevant point here is that the film starts with a visiting flying saucer chucking out an almost-empty bottle of Coke® whose residue evolves into our entire ecosystem. Well worth a rental.
That’s how the ‘Cambrian Explosion’ got started, according to a Si-Fi story about 40 years ago, except in the story the aliens buried their waste, but not well enough.
Bilan about 5 years ago
It’s not like Eddy made this up, it’s an old theory, The World According to Glump.
mr_sherman Premium Member about 5 years ago
You’re old, Eddie.
RAGs about 5 years ago
Can a person be “old” if they never grow up?
AllishaDawn about 5 years ago
Isn’t grandma older than Eddie?
sirbadger about 5 years ago
Did Eddie and his boat catch God in the act of creating life?
Dtroutma about 5 years ago
Did she get it from Paulie?
Radish... about 5 years ago
Yeah but where did the alien life come from?
Concretionist about 5 years ago
It’s been done, at least twice that I know of: Science Fiction. One almost exactly like this but without the “tribal elder” bit; the other “something disgusting” but as a tribal story of creation.
Of course Danae wasn’t doing “science” she was doing “sociology”. Or just “story collection”.
Say What Now‽ Premium Member about 5 years ago
And then there was that alien race that dropped those dang Thetans in the volcano.
JasonBall about 5 years ago
This is hilarious. As soon as she says “so I went to the oldest person I know” I was laughing. An unusual, but not unwelcome, strip that combines Danae and Eddy.
eastern.woods.metal about 5 years ago
That’s about as accurate as Calvin’s dad telling him the trees make the wind blow
Watcher about 5 years ago
Danae, you did the research, a little flawed, but your methodology wasn’t so your grade should be a passing one and for a child your age, very creative.
tonypezzano about 5 years ago
More coherent than Prometheus.
keenanthelibrarian about 5 years ago
Well I can think of older sources – nevertheless Danae’s take seems about as legitimate as most of ’em.
Gary Williams Premium Member about 5 years ago
How do you know it ain"t true?
chazkclines about 5 years ago
Makes about as much sense as a god creating life.
Lyons Group, Inc. about 5 years ago
We’ll stick with creation, thank you.
JRMadDog Premium Member about 5 years ago
Based on recent events, I find much credence in this theory. Stinky is as stinky does … or something like that.
Kombul Premium Member about 5 years ago
Actually Stanislav Lem wrote a story about life on Earth coming into existence due to pollution in the 1960s or 1970s
Ignatz Premium Member about 5 years ago
What scares me is that this seems plausible.
dot-the-I about 5 years ago
First panel triggered a memory and a smile: MST3K
johndifool about 5 years ago
Space Giraffes?
YulanaLow Premium Member about 5 years ago
Oral history most often has deviated from the original telling.
oakie817 about 5 years ago
very nice ‘teamup’
Bill The Nuke about 5 years ago
I make stuff up for my granddaughter but she’s smart enough (experienced enough?) to know when I’m kidding.
Redd Panda about 5 years ago
You can do this experiment at home, kids. Fill your bathtub with warm water, add some sewage and wait. You’ll be amazed at what grows in that soup. guiliani worms, pence sludge, conway suckers and the apex creature, the trump slug. Please wash you hands when done.
vaughnrl2003 Premium Member about 5 years ago
Tribal knowledge is important. Individual knowledge is important. Knowing the difference? Priceless.
sandpiper about 5 years ago
This was a science report. Accuracy was only implied.
Kabana_Bhoy about 5 years ago
It could happen…
xtc45688 about 5 years ago
Shouldn’t it be his " Eahs ah bahnin."?
yipp_eeee about 5 years ago
So it was Space Giraffes?? Sounds legit.
JodyDickerson1 about 5 years ago
That’s like a Stanilaw Lem short story about two space travelers, Gord and Lod, contaminating a planet with their spit, only to later give rise to humanity. I think it’s the Intergalactic Congress and it is in the collection the cyberiad. The origin story is brought to light as Earth tries to gain membership
Diamond Lil about 5 years ago
Ah…my ex, explained perfectly!
yimhere about 5 years ago
Clearly more fake news from Paulie!
eastern.woods.metal about 5 years ago
Fox news is diversifying ?
Old27F20 about 5 years ago
GASP!!!, Its her! Look at the fish on the left side, its my third grade teacher miss Julian!! I’d know that face anywhere! I knew there was something fishy about her eyes!.
Bicycle Dude about 5 years ago
One can only wonder what that text message says.
Godfreydaniel about 5 years ago
Cap’n Eddie isn’t old, he’s in the prime of his delusions!
David_J Premium Member about 5 years ago
I love the raised eyebrow in the 7th panel. LoL
And So It Goes about 5 years ago
All things came into existence, where and when we do not know.All things will cease to exist, when we do not know. As I age I realize, I will some day cease to exist,when I do not know, nor do I care to!Life is a journey to be lived and I intend to live it as long as I can!
timbob2313 Premium Member about 5 years ago
The “Christians”-the ones always protesting the teaching of Evolution-think that a “god”-and actual person/race of “people” are the ones who created life on earth. So Danae, at least according to the hyper xristians who believe that the world is only 5000 years old and Dinosaur bones were planted by this same"group" is correct
timbob2313 Premium Member about 5 years ago
I get it now, they were dumping their garbage, which eventually turned into all of us, who are still dumping our garbage in the oceans
DanFlak about 5 years ago
Well, that’s one version of panspermia.
Richard S Russell Premium Member about 5 years ago
Bruno Bozzetto’s 1976 Italian animated film Allegro Non Troppo (musical direction for “fast but not too fast”) is a takeoff on Disney’s Fantasia in that it’s an anthology of fantastical short stories (many of them humorous) that also makes extensive use of classical music as background. The relevant point here is that the film starts with a visiting flying saucer chucking out an almost-empty bottle of Coke® whose residue evolves into our entire ecosystem. Well worth a rental.
Sun about 5 years ago
Respect microbes, they’re the only culture that people have.
MCProfessor about 5 years ago
A Plausible theory.
bakana about 5 years ago
So, she asked the Cat?
STACEY MARSHALL Premium Member about 5 years ago
That’s how the ‘Cambrian Explosion’ got started, according to a Si-Fi story about 40 years ago, except in the story the aliens buried their waste, but not well enough.
JimCashman Premium Member about 5 years ago
I just LOVE Danae’s version. Once we get faster than light space travel we may do the same to some other “barren” planet.
DarkMater about 5 years ago
Nice, not-so-hidden message on the control panel. Approved!
cwg about 5 years ago
Eddie, they should be exploding into flames.
sperry532 about 5 years ago
I seem to recall this being the basis of an animated short. I think it might have been Heavy Metal, but I don’t remember.
falcon_370f about 5 years ago
The irony is that the only thing Danae had wrong (according to Darwin) was the aliens.
whitecarabao about 5 years ago
Love it!
57BelAir about 5 years ago
This is a really funny one…love it, plus it has inspired many good comments.
57BelAir about 5 years ago
Notice the alien writing could be read as “clump dump”