Yes, Kaya.. A positive integer n has an odd number of divisors if and only if n is a … 4k + 1. ) . 1. 2 n−1. ∑ k=0. (. 4n. 4(n – 1 – k)1. ) … xn = nxn−1 + n n – 2.
Hope that helped!
LOL
.
Nice to see a new face in the strip, though, it would have been cool seeing Fay, again.
Is that even a valid mathematical question? An array is a set of numbers ordered in any number of dimensions. She mentions NxN, indicating that it’s a two dimensional array, N numbers wide and N numbers high. The formula N=4k+2, gives n=6 when k=1, 10 when N=2 and 14 for N=3. but what sort of solution is the girl asking for? She asked asked any question, only defined a series of arrays.
Also I think Greg really needs to stop trying to draw ethnics. This girl is not as bad as Sun was but still winch-inducing.
Finally aren’t tutors selected by the fields they are good in? Sending an English major to tutor a math student seems a waste of both people;s time.
So end another series of strips involving Luann and her foibles with a gag finish. Next week on to something new, but we will return to Homework Helpers again.
Would it have been that hard to dig up an actual AP-level math problem? I don’t know why, but seeing that gibberish just irks me. (Yeah, it’s gibberish: I’ve got a PhD in math.)
Uh. What is an array of NxN? And what does the rest of that gibberish mean? (My high school math classes that i took before heading to university were my lowest grades ever…. 53%in algebra, 57% in relations and functions and 66% in calculus) I had no choice but to be an English major, and have the life time career as a retail shelf stocker to show how useful that education was.
I believe there are specialized tutors for each subject. Or does this student simply the answers to her homework, and not so much for learning the concept or improving study habits?
As a former tutor for the college math department, the correct first response to Kaya’s question or one like it is: “Good question! Let’s find out together!”
G&K must have pulled this problem out of an old math book… Otherwise, it seems like there’s some thing a bit “stereotypical” about this… “Asian kid loves math”..
My question is when will the GOP decide that math is as dangerous as books seem to be these days. Censorship is the strongest drive on earth; sex, a weak second.
Sadly, it is common for teachers to have poor command of their subject matter. It demonstrates that teachers are often part of a job program and also there to help indoctrinate kids to the woke ideology. Not most of them, but a large minority of them.
Not sure where this arc is going, but maybe they should concentrate on matching Luann’s skills with the student’s needs. Unless, of course, their actual intention is to make Luann look like a total nincompoop. Eons ago, I enjoyed Student Teacher Day at my high school, and loved assisting in our English Department’s Creative Writing Class. But if I were to try assisting with our Math department …… Ay Yo! Fuggetta ‘bout id!!! Oh well, we’ll see what Monday brings.
Better do a comic crossover and call Jason from Foxtrot. While you are there, see if you can get a date with Peter and your boyfriend problems will be solved!!!
ANOTHER Asian kid who knows more than the teacher!? Gad, I am so sick of this cliche, it insults all hardworking Americans, and the Communists do enough of that. You know what would help our kids do better in school? STOP CUTTING THEIR FUNDING AT EVERY TURN!
And another storyarc ends with G&K crapping on their main character. Though really, the blame for this situation lies with Luann’s boss for assigning her this kid. If you need a military helicopter flown from point A to point B, you don’t tell an infantryman to fly it; no, you call a pilot. And conversely, you wouldn’t ask the pilot to conduct infantry operations.
This stunning misallocation of resources is further evidence that Mrs Fogarty is about as useful as a glass hammer.
Our kid’s middle school had free night refresher courses for math so parents could help their kids with the math homework. The classes were always full.
Luann wasn’t always such a mundane character in the strip. Right now, she comes across as your favorite maiden Aunt. Ever since the group split up between Mooney U. and Pitts C.C. the group dynamic has crashed. Quill was introduced in November, 2009. The tension between Luann and Tiffany around Quill carried the strip shifting to the sexual tension between Luann and Quill. Around this time Brad and Toni were Brad and Toni were a hot item and Nancy was cool toward here. The strip was loaded with drama.
Then something changed around 2016. There was the Big Wedding, then… Luann and Quill break up. Tiffany pal zones Gunther. Luann pal zones Gunther. After she pal zones him, Tiff’s attempt to hook up Gunther and Bernice fails.
Except for Gunther, nothing has “clicked” since then.
You know what? This one was funny. Luann should’ve written on whatever application she filled out regarding which subjects she’s willing to help with, “Math? No thanks”.
Boy, can I relate to this! When I was a teacher, I once went for an interview for a teaching job on a military post. I was told that I would be expected to teach English, a subject in which I minored, and did quite well. Then, the other shoe dropped when he said I would also be expected to teach math, a subject in which I did miserably, and in which I tended to turn numbers around. I stopped the interview right then and there, and told the man that I didn’t want to waste any more of his time, because there was no way I could teach math. As I got up to leave, I still remembered the shocked look on his face.
Above is an example of a 4×4 Graeco-Latin square: 16 combinations of two attributes—rank and suit—arranged in a 4×4 array with each rank (J, Q, K, A) appearing exactly once in each row and once in each column, each suit (clubs, diamonds, hearts, spades) appearing once in each row and once in each column, and each rank paired exactly once with each suit (no two cards alike).
If you add a fifth rank (say, 2) and fifth suit (say, pretzels) you can find 5×5 examples, such as this one:
JC QD KP AS 2H
KS AH 2C JD QP
2D JP QS KH AC
QH KC AD 2P JS
AP 2S JH KC QD
What about 6×6? 7×7? …? (Assume you get to invent as many ranks and suits as you need.)
I speculate that Kaya left out the beginning of her problem and that “a solution to an array of N×N” is an attempt (slightly garbled by Kaya and/or her teacher and by Greg and/or Karen) to say “an N×N Graeco-Latin square”. With this interpretation, the problem would be simple enough for a middle schooler to understand (if they’re not so math-phobic that they shut off their brain before they even try), but outrageously difficult to actually solve.
For more, including where the N = 4K+2 part comes in, see this Numberphile video:
My apology if someone already mentioned this possibility. What if Kaya is really needing tutoring in writing or English or something that Luann is good at. But she’s just throwing out this math problem because she’s good at math and is kind of “teasing” Luann with this question?
We haven’t seen a Les arc in a while. Maybe something with him and Tiff. The Evans have flirted with that many times. I.e., the Gray dinner, the Eiffel fetus picture reveal, 30JAN2018 – Last Gunther/Les spat over Tiffany’s attention, 5JUN2018 Tiff put a move on Les, 19APR2019, 8AUG2019 Les asks Tiff to move in with him, 21&22JUL2020 the latest kiss incident.
It seems to be moving that way. It even makes some sort of sense when you consider this: https://www.gocomics.com/luann/2017/06/13.
lvlax over 2 years ago
Yes, Kaya.. A positive integer n has an odd number of divisors if and only if n is a … 4k + 1. ) . 1. 2 n−1. ∑ k=0. (. 4n. 4(n – 1 – k)1. ) … xn = nxn−1 + n n – 2.
Hope that helped!
LOL.
Nice to see a new face in the strip, though, it would have been cool seeing Fay, again.
beb01 over 2 years ago
Is that even a valid mathematical question? An array is a set of numbers ordered in any number of dimensions. She mentions NxN, indicating that it’s a two dimensional array, N numbers wide and N numbers high. The formula N=4k+2, gives n=6 when k=1, 10 when N=2 and 14 for N=3. but what sort of solution is the girl asking for? She asked asked any question, only defined a series of arrays.
Also I think Greg really needs to stop trying to draw ethnics. This girl is not as bad as Sun was but still winch-inducing.
Finally aren’t tutors selected by the fields they are good in? Sending an English major to tutor a math student seems a waste of both people;s time.
Templo S.U.D. over 2 years ago
Tutoring sure looks tough, doesn’t it, Luann?
AnyFace over 2 years ago
Too rich for my blood. ✨
Tyge over 2 years ago
SO! There are some knottier problems than a dealing with hormonal new-teens!
Rhetorical_Question over 2 years ago
Where is the humor?
Cheapskate0 over 2 years ago
Man, G&K love trashing Luann.
Now, I admit that Luann is not my favorite character in this strip, but no one deserves to be treated this way – especially by their creators!
Rhetorical_Question over 2 years ago
Does Kaya have braces?
Tyge over 2 years ago
So end another series of strips involving Luann and her foibles with a gag finish. Next week on to something new, but we will return to Homework Helpers again.
Rhetorical_Question over 2 years ago
Does Luann know what an integer is?
Tyge over 2 years ago
From panel 3, Greg must be the solution.
ronaldspence over 2 years ago
Luann is back!
yoey1957 over 2 years ago
I’m in my 60’s, math and I have not been on speaking terms since the 2nd grade.
reedkomicks Premium Member over 2 years ago
Haha funny, and cute!
rklynch over 2 years ago
Not in my lifetime either. Like really, how is anyone supposed to understand THAT????
Ahuehuete over 2 years ago
Better call Gunth!
NotAllMelancholy over 2 years ago
Would it have been that hard to dig up an actual AP-level math problem? I don’t know why, but seeing that gibberish just irks me. (Yeah, it’s gibberish: I’ve got a PhD in math.)
Enter.Name.Here over 2 years ago
Future rocket scientist.
Joe1962 over 2 years ago
What it is use for.
TheThingIs over 2 years ago
First Asian-American character. That’s awesome.
Willow Mt Lyon over 2 years ago
Kaya has braces. Cute. My sons had them, and now my older grandchildren have them.
B UTTONS over 2 years ago
Can I call a friend?
Hello, Sheldon Cooper please.
DirkTheDaring Premium Member over 2 years ago
This stereotype of a smart, math-oriented Asian girl really hurts. If we find out she plays violin too, then we have a real problem.
kenhense over 2 years ago
A new face. Hopefully now, a new and interesting plot.
capricorn9th over 2 years ago
Kaya does not need a tutor.
Susan00100 over 2 years ago
Is that kid wearing braces or dentures??
BTW, the answer to her problem is 4n to the 10th power squared!! ;-)
Mordock999 Premium Member over 2 years ago
Hmmm.
Kaya doesn’t strike Me as someone having “problems” with her schoolwork to the point that she’d need Luann’s services.
And YES. It is a pleasure to see a new character in the Strip for a change.
Short-lived though she may be.
californiamonty over 2 years ago
Doesn’t Kaya look like Khan Junior from King of the Hill?
Aladar30 Premium Member over 2 years ago
Oh no, not the math problem! At least Kaya seems to be a good student and she finds Luann funny. Let’s hope they get along well.
theincrediblebulk over 2 years ago
Uh. What is an array of NxN? And what does the rest of that gibberish mean? (My high school math classes that i took before heading to university were my lowest grades ever…. 53%in algebra, 57% in relations and functions and 66% in calculus) I had no choice but to be an English major, and have the life time career as a retail shelf stocker to show how useful that education was.
sueb1863 over 2 years ago
Wouldn’t they assign Kaya a math tutor for help with math homework? That seems pretty specialized.
Caldonia over 2 years ago
Now I’m wondering if the Axel crush will ever come up again and we’re just going to go through some pupil audition shtick for awhile! Fascinating.
OneTime59 over 2 years ago
I believe there are specialized tutors for each subject. Or does this student simply the answers to her homework, and not so much for learning the concept or improving study habits?
dadoctah over 2 years ago
As a former tutor for the college math department, the correct first response to Kaya’s question or one like it is: “Good question! Let’s find out together!”
Johnnyrico over 2 years ago
G&K must have pulled this problem out of an old math book… Otherwise, it seems like there’s some thing a bit “stereotypical” about this… “Asian kid loves math”..
Skeptical Meg over 2 years ago
“Yes. Next problem!”
Ellis97 over 2 years ago
Luann doesn’t know much math, just like myself.
Frank Farkel over 2 years ago
My question is when will the GOP decide that math is as dangerous as books seem to be these days. Censorship is the strongest drive on earth; sex, a weak second.
luann1212 over 2 years ago
Ah, teachers are supposed to know everything.
ctolson over 2 years ago
If K is only defined as a positive integer, then there is an infinite number of solutions as K can be any positive integer you want.
Johnnyrico over 2 years ago
I doubt that Luann even knows what an integer is…. Gunther to the rescue!
Free or Not? Premium Member over 2 years ago
Sadly, it is common for teachers to have poor command of their subject matter. It demonstrates that teachers are often part of a job program and also there to help indoctrinate kids to the woke ideology. Not most of them, but a large minority of them.
PaulAbbott2 over 2 years ago
I’m with you Luann. I would have understood more of that if she had been speaking Mongolian
cdillon85 over 2 years ago
Bl**** show-off. (That’s my way of saying ‘Nice work’!)
D.E.N. over 2 years ago
Not sure where this arc is going, but maybe they should concentrate on matching Luann’s skills with the student’s needs. Unless, of course, their actual intention is to make Luann look like a total nincompoop. Eons ago, I enjoyed Student Teacher Day at my high school, and loved assisting in our English Department’s Creative Writing Class. But if I were to try assisting with our Math department …… Ay Yo! Fuggetta ‘bout id!!! Oh well, we’ll see what Monday brings.
ajr58(1) over 2 years ago
42.
atomicdog over 2 years ago
It would have been real funny if she actually knew the answer.
locake over 2 years ago
Sometimes the math problem would say Find X. I would point it out in the equation, “there’s the X”.
jea9hrkr over 2 years ago
I don’t think they should’ve promoted stereotype.
I'm Sad over 2 years ago
Better do a comic crossover and call Jason from Foxtrot. While you are there, see if you can get a date with Peter and your boyfriend problems will be solved!!!
CoreyTaylor1 over 2 years ago
ANOTHER Asian kid who knows more than the teacher!? Gad, I am so sick of this cliche, it insults all hardworking Americans, and the Communists do enough of that. You know what would help our kids do better in school? STOP CUTTING THEIR FUNDING AT EVERY TURN!
comic reader 22 over 2 years ago
Just askin’ – but shouldn’t a “homework helper” be sufficiently educated in all of the school curriculum that is being taught?
BJShipley1 over 2 years ago
And another storyarc ends with G&K crapping on their main character. Though really, the blame for this situation lies with Luann’s boss for assigning her this kid. If you need a military helicopter flown from point A to point B, you don’t tell an infantryman to fly it; no, you call a pilot. And conversely, you wouldn’t ask the pilot to conduct infantry operations.
This stunning misallocation of resources is further evidence that Mrs Fogarty is about as useful as a glass hammer.
Same2Ubuddy over 2 years ago
Based on her appearance, I would have thought she needed help with driving.
Robert Wilson Premium Member over 2 years ago
Our kid’s middle school had free night refresher courses for math so parents could help their kids with the math homework. The classes were always full.
Jogger2 over 2 years ago
What does it mean to find a solution of a square array??
If the elements of a square array are each a number, is it the array the same as a square matrix?
Tyge over 2 years ago
Luann wasn’t always such a mundane character in the strip. Right now, she comes across as your favorite maiden Aunt. Ever since the group split up between Mooney U. and Pitts C.C. the group dynamic has crashed. Quill was introduced in November, 2009. The tension between Luann and Tiffany around Quill carried the strip shifting to the sexual tension between Luann and Quill. Around this time Brad and Toni were Brad and Toni were a hot item and Nancy was cool toward here. The strip was loaded with drama.
Then something changed around 2016. There was the Big Wedding, then… Luann and Quill break up. Tiffany pal zones Gunther. Luann pal zones Gunther. After she pal zones him, Tiff’s attempt to hook up Gunther and Bernice fails.
Except for Gunther, nothing has “clicked” since then.
Otis Rufus Driftwood over 2 years ago
Good to see Luann back on the bicycle again.
mindjob over 2 years ago
She should go to Harvard but because of quotas, she won’t get in
Decepticomic over 2 years ago
You know what? This one was funny. Luann should’ve written on whatever application she filled out regarding which subjects she’s willing to help with, “Math? No thanks”.
leighabc123 over 2 years ago
Luann, it’s time to switch to kindergarten tutoring. Middle school is not for you!
Lola85 Premium Member over 2 years ago
Boy, can I relate to this! When I was a teacher, I once went for an interview for a teaching job on a military post. I was told that I would be expected to teach English, a subject in which I minored, and did quite well. Then, the other shoe dropped when he said I would also be expected to teach math, a subject in which I did miserably, and in which I tended to turn numbers around. I stopped the interview right then and there, and told the man that I didn’t want to waste any more of his time, because there was no way I could teach math. As I got up to leave, I still remembered the shocked look on his face.
The Quiet One over 2 years ago
Are we sure this student needs assistance. She could school Luann.
Treehggr87 Premium Member over 2 years ago
Today’s strip gives me hives!
xaingo over 2 years ago
Is Kaya looking at the invisible camera in the first panel?
huntoonjunk over 2 years ago
Obviously the answer is 42. Even Beeblebrox knows that!
BuckarooDave over 2 years ago
tomorrow: Toni and Brad do their taxes
kmccjoe1 over 2 years ago
Don’t get me wrong, I like Luann, but this has to be the funniest intentional thing she has ever said in this strip.
outonalimb over 2 years ago
J♣️ Q♦️ K❤️ A♠️
K♠️ A❤️ J♦️ Q♣️
A♦️ K♣️ Q♠️ J❤️
Q❤️ J♠️ A♣️ K♦️
Above is an example of a 4×4 Graeco-Latin square: 16 combinations of two attributes—rank and suit—arranged in a 4×4 array with each rank (J, Q, K, A) appearing exactly once in each row and once in each column, each suit (clubs, diamonds, hearts, spades) appearing once in each row and once in each column, and each rank paired exactly once with each suit (no two cards alike).
If you add a fifth rank (say, 2) and fifth suit (say, pretzels) you can find 5×5 examples, such as this one:
JC QD KP AS 2H
KS AH 2C JD QP
2D JP QS KH AC
QH KC AD 2P JS
AP 2S JH KC QD
What about 6×6? 7×7? …? (Assume you get to invent as many ranks and suits as you need.)
I speculate that Kaya left out the beginning of her problem and that “a solution to an array of N×N” is an attempt (slightly garbled by Kaya and/or her teacher and by Greg and/or Karen) to say “an N×N Graeco-Latin square”. With this interpretation, the problem would be simple enough for a middle schooler to understand (if they’re not so math-phobic that they shut off their brain before they even try), but outrageously difficult to actually solve.
For more, including where the N = 4K+2 part comes in, see this Numberphile video:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qu04xLNrk94
David Huie Green LoveJoyAndPeace over 2 years ago
And leaving the integer set, how many in the complex number set?
oakie817 over 2 years ago
oh Kaya’s a keeper…wonder if she knows Axel
dv1093 over 2 years ago
The numbers don’t lie – Cute Kid!
seismic-2 Premium Member over 2 years ago
Monday: Gunther and Les sit around the house.
TampaFanatic1 over 2 years ago
Perhaps Luann’s destiny is not as a teacher but in the realm of Uber or pizza delivery. Man G&K have her as a major league buffoon recently.
hoffquotes2 over 2 years ago
Luann should major in business, she has a business to inherit someday
edeloriea14 over 2 years ago
Kaya must be a child prodigy.
Sisyphos over 2 years ago
I’m thinking Kaya does not need a tutor, and most certainly not Luann!
Night-Gaunt49[Bozo is Boffo] over 2 years ago
Good answer Luann!
DaBump Premium Member over 2 years ago
Somebody’s got a tiger mom…
finnygirl Premium Member over 2 years ago
My apology if someone already mentioned this possibility. What if Kaya is really needing tutoring in writing or English or something that Luann is good at. But she’s just throwing out this math problem because she’s good at math and is kind of “teasing” Luann with this question?
Tyge over 2 years ago
We haven’t seen a Les arc in a while. Maybe something with him and Tiff. The Evans have flirted with that many times. I.e., the Gray dinner, the Eiffel fetus picture reveal, 30JAN2018 – Last Gunther/Les spat over Tiffany’s attention, 5JUN2018 Tiff put a move on Les, 19APR2019, 8AUG2019 Les asks Tiff to move in with him, 21&22JUL2020 the latest kiss incident.
It seems to be moving that way. It even makes some sort of sense when you consider this: https://www.gocomics.com/luann/2017/06/13.
Doctor Go over 2 years ago
This must be the Foxtrot / Luann crossover strip.
jr1234 over 2 years ago
420 PM CT..many GoComics are not working, I see no toons.
Anyone else experiencing this?
And can’t bring up the calendar, only can hit arrows to change the date..
An hour earlier it was working
patrickab7 over 2 years ago
…I USED to know that… T_T