The gender thing is only in other languages, Calvin. But it’s complicated because a noun in French may be masculine but in Spanish it may be feminine. That makes things more complicated! English is hard enough without all that so be thankful.
When I first encountered Spanish, I had no idea about such things and just kind of picked it up a bit. Then I found out about el mapa (among other absurdities). Though there is a very VERY minor advantage: “las lunas” is a bunch of moons, but “Los Lunas” is the town that grew up where great grandpa Luna settled.
It’s not an unreasonable question. English must have had gendered nouns at some time, as both the Latin and the Teutonic languages do. How about the Celtic languages? I’m not sure. I wonder when we left off using them and why? Some dialects still have the odd gendered words.
When I took German in high school, I had no trouble with the vocabulary lists, except for grammatical gender. I suppose it seems natural if you grow up with it, but I wonder if even Germans get it wrong sometimes.
The teacher should know that English lost grammatical gender in early Middle English as the adjectives lost their endings. By the time of Geoffrey Chaucer, English had natural gender and adjectives added an -e with plural nouns. Of course, then that -e dropped or disappeared with adjective ending in -e. Anyone who studied Indo-European languages would know that each language treats the gender of its nouns differently. In French, sun is masculine and moon is feminine. In German, it’s the opposite. In Polish, sun is neuter and moon is masculine, but stars are feminine. If Calvin be so inclined, he should study Old English to learn the grammatical genders of nouns.
“Desk” is neuter, “chair” is masculine. If we go through the rest of the classroom, “floor” and “ceiling” are both neuter, “wall” and “window” are both masculine, and “blackboard” and “chalk” are both feminine, as is “door”. “Classroom” is feminine, and “teacher” is masculine (even if it’s a woman). At least, that’s the way it is in Icelandic classrooms.
Adding gender to nouns is presumptive, we do it know the gender they associate with, what their genders are, and even if they have genders. Ask yourself, how does a male cat feel about being tagged with a feminine noun?
Yes, I’m being silly … maybe that’s my proper gender?
Unfortunately Calvin English does not use gender nouns or gender much as a matter of fact, German does a bit but I recommend you take a romance language like Spanish or French in High School as a second language.
And here we have to wonder if we use the right gender pronoun on PEOPLE!!… At least if you call a dining room table by the wrong pronoun, they don’t get all shook up by it and call you names !
This comic and comments has been a little strange for me as I don’t ever recall being taught that objects have genders. I always thought that just humans and animals have genders- male and female.
Funny – I never saw Calvin as all that woke before.
Actually, most nouns are gendered in other languages – like French or Spanish – it’s just that wierdo language English that assumes everything is gender-neutral
BE THIS GUY 10 months ago
The medication takes a liquid form when she gets home.
codycab 10 months ago
Wait until high school, Calvin. Assuming you’ll get there, that is.
JïllDérs(TOMGF) 10 months ago
English doesn’t use gender for words Calvin makes things much easier
Firebat 10 months ago
Gender wars… 1994 style!
SHIVA 10 months ago
The little cretin will drive anyone to drink!!!
snsurone76 10 months ago
Don’t waste your breath, Calvin. The Republican Party would ban any form of sex education in public schools!
fuzzbucket Premium Member 10 months ago
Is Ms Wormwood old? All us geezers take meds by the dozen.
c001 10 months ago
Calm down, Calvin. Be glad that you don’t have six different words for “the” like we have.
GROG Premium Member 10 months ago
If it wasn’t for you, she wouldn’t need those meds.
Macushlalondra 10 months ago
The gender thing is only in other languages, Calvin. But it’s complicated because a noun in French may be masculine but in Spanish it may be feminine. That makes things more complicated! English is hard enough without all that so be thankful.
BigDaveGlass 10 months ago
Calvin? Demanding to be educated? Who are you, and what have you done with him?
Concretionist 10 months ago
When I first encountered Spanish, I had no idea about such things and just kind of picked it up a bit. Then I found out about el mapa (among other absurdities). Though there is a very VERY minor advantage: “las lunas” is a bunch of moons, but “Los Lunas” is the town that grew up where great grandpa Luna settled.
su43dipta 10 months ago
That’s not what Sex Ed is, Calvin.
robinafox 10 months ago
It’s not an unreasonable question. English must have had gendered nouns at some time, as both the Latin and the Teutonic languages do. How about the Celtic languages? I’m not sure. I wonder when we left off using them and why? Some dialects still have the odd gendered words.
Troglodyte 10 months ago
I’m thankful that English doesn’t have this particular “problem”!
Kaputnik 10 months ago
When I took German in high school, I had no trouble with the vocabulary lists, except for grammatical gender. I suppose it seems natural if you grow up with it, but I wonder if even Germans get it wrong sometimes.
eced52 10 months ago
Sure this wasn’t written last week?
Count Olaf Premium Member 10 months ago
Now days one can’t even be sure about a person. Happy Birthday Elliot/Ellen Page.
VegaAlopex 10 months ago
The teacher should know that English lost grammatical gender in early Middle English as the adjectives lost their endings. By the time of Geoffrey Chaucer, English had natural gender and adjectives added an -e with plural nouns. Of course, then that -e dropped or disappeared with adjective ending in -e. Anyone who studied Indo-European languages would know that each language treats the gender of its nouns differently. In French, sun is masculine and moon is feminine. In German, it’s the opposite. In Polish, sun is neuter and moon is masculine, but stars are feminine. If Calvin be so inclined, he should study Old English to learn the grammatical genders of nouns.
KageKat 10 months ago
I don’t know WHY it is, but it’s just not a feature like it is for the Romance languages.
tremaine53 10 months ago
That’s heroin you see Miss Wormwood using there, Calvin.
Purple People Eater 10 months ago
“Desk” is neuter, “chair” is masculine. If we go through the rest of the classroom, “floor” and “ceiling” are both neuter, “wall” and “window” are both masculine, and “blackboard” and “chalk” are both feminine, as is “door”. “Classroom” is feminine, and “teacher” is masculine (even if it’s a woman). At least, that’s the way it is in Icelandic classrooms.
Link from Twilight Princess (He/Him) 10 months ago
“I DEMAND A SEX EDUCATION”Add that to the “Calvin out of Context” compilation.
chaosed2 10 months ago
and now we have to worry about misgendering the desk….
djtenltd 10 months ago
With Calvin, Ms. Wormworth had BETTER have meds being that she’s not allowed to have any Jack Daniels or Absolut Vodka! LOL!!
happyinvenice23 10 months ago
Sex Ed should began in middle school, this is very important for all children to learn and understand where and how our lives began.
More Coffee Please! Premium Member 10 months ago
He’s love many European countries then…
Droptma Styx 10 months ago
Be thankful English doesn’t insist on genderizing all nouns. (Is that even a word in English?)
I'm Sad 10 months ago
Bill Watterson, future prognosticator.
steveconkey2003 10 months ago
If he only knew what was to come from the left.
dflak 10 months ago
It is bad enough that we are stuck with he, she, him, her, his, hers.
Although it does come in handy sometimes like, “She told him to take her car,” instead of “She told him to take his car.”
david_42 10 months ago
Since English is three languages in a trench coat, which source’s gender would we use?
jagedlo 10 months ago
“Doc, can you increase the dosage…these medications don’t seem to be working!”
Autological 10 months ago
Why would Calvin be confused by the multitude of genders for people? There are only two of them. Not that confusing, even for Calvin.
poppacapsmokeblower 10 months ago
Adding gender to nouns is presumptive, we do it know the gender they associate with, what their genders are, and even if they have genders. Ask yourself, how does a male cat feel about being tagged with a feminine noun?
Yes, I’m being silly … maybe that’s my proper gender?
aerotica69 10 months ago
So many people who can’t figure out their own gender, and Calvin wants us to worry about desks and chairs?
Michael Helwig 10 months ago
Get some sex education Calvin and you won’t ever look at Susie the same way again.
Redd Panda 10 months ago
You can tell this strip is 20 years old.
Just-me 10 months ago
Oh so many thoughts to express, I won’t though, except for this one about so many thoughts.
KEA 10 months ago
we used to post these in the teachers lounge
dsom8 10 months ago
Oh how much has changed since this was published.
minty_Joe 10 months ago
Reminds me of the Monty Python skit about woody and tinny words.
Https://Www.youtube.Com/watch?v=-gwXJsWHupg
g04922 10 months ago
LOL….Calvin is destined for Special Ed.
ladykat 10 months ago
Actually, desk and chair are neuter, Calvin.
Steverino Premium Member 10 months ago
I have always considered kitchen islands to be female.
After all, no man is an island.
kinich79 10 months ago
Unfortunately Calvin English does not use gender nouns or gender much as a matter of fact, German does a bit but I recommend you take a romance language like Spanish or French in High School as a second language.
wiley207 10 months ago
I dunno, “chair” sounds kind of masculine as well.
John Jorgensen 10 months ago
My uncle was once asked by his French teacher how he could tell whether pen was masculine or feminine. He answered “I would look under its drawers.”
In retrospect, she really teed him up for that one.
mistercatworks 10 months ago
English is a nonbinary language – so far ahead of its time. :)
stamps 10 months ago
Le Bureau. La chaise. There, I said it. DeSantis can sue me if he likes.
DKHenderson 10 months ago
It is a good question. Why DON’T English speakers have noun genders? Is it because our “THE” is neutral?
slbolfing 10 months ago
Calvin will end up drivin’ a hot-rod Lincoln…
EMGULS79 10 months ago
One of the funniest episodes of “Emily In Paris” pondered the mystery of why, in French, it’s “LE vagin.”
willie_mctell 10 months ago
Where did Calvin learn about the fine points of grammar?
pchemcat 10 months ago
I will have to admit, that is one thing that I don’t understand with some languages. That was the hardest part for me learning French and Spanish.
tammyspeakslife Premium Member 10 months ago
As a child I thought that some numbers had genders, 7 was female, 8 & 9 were male.
Redd Panda 10 months ago
At six, what experience does Calvin have with other languages?
suelou 10 months ago
And here we have to wonder if we use the right gender pronoun on PEOPLE!!… At least if you call a dining room table by the wrong pronoun, they don’t get all shook up by it and call you names !
jbruins84341 10 months ago
English used to have genders, but not anymore, thank goodness!
weatherford.joe 10 months ago
I wonder what kind of meds she takes. I know it was mentioned she chugs Maalox from the bottle.
Sambora1 10 months ago
This comic and comments has been a little strange for me as I don’t ever recall being taught that objects have genders. I always thought that just humans and animals have genders- male and female.
M2MM 10 months ago
THIS will never get old… :D
johnec 10 months ago
Funny – I never saw Calvin as all that woke before.
Actually, most nouns are gendered in other languages – like French or Spanish – it’s just that wierdo language English that assumes everything is gender-neutral
kamoolah 10 months ago
Calvin goes to a segregated school. There are no children of color in his class.
Gus the goose 10 months ago
This is a rare occasion this comic is from Febuary 26 2014 and the next one after this is from febuary 27 2014.